Skip to main content
Read page text
page 4
FEATURES / Anglican rifts PHOTO: ST EBBE’S CHURCH, OXFORD Sunday worship at St Ebbe’s Church, Oxford The established Church is used to living with fractures and diversity while maintaining a coherent identity. The looming divide over same-sex blessings threatens a deeper and more fundamental structural division / By THEO HOBSON Will evangelicals split the C of E? THE CHURCH of England is changing its position on homosexuality. Its General Synod has voted in favour of same-sex blessings, and the ban on clergy marrying same-sex partners is likely to be lifted soon. Leading evangelicals have made it clear that they can only stay in the Church of England if they are allowed a clear structure of their own, maybe even a province of their own, alongside Canterbury and York. Some even suggest that Canterbury should be given to them, and York left to the liberals. Is the Church of England finally coming apart? Let’s take a step back. The Church of England has always had a minority that emphasises biblical faith and is suspicious of both its Catholic and its liberal wing. For most of Anglican history, that suspicion was easily outweighed by a belief in a strong national Protestant Church. A sense of momentum, rooted in national purpose, held the Church together. About 40 years ago the Church lost that momentum. The evangelicals felt freer to express their dismay at the Church’s liberal direction. And they felt emboldened by their relative success: their pews filled, as other pews thinned, and many well-funded parishes became hubs of energy, and sources of churchplanting. What complicates this shifting powerbalance is that evangelicalism sits awkwardly within the C of E. As the established Church it is tied to the political and cultural liberalism of the nation, but evangelicalism has a counter-cultural aura. Also, its belief that the Spirit creates congregations of committed Christians sits uneasily with the parish system, in which different sorts of Christians, including lukewarm ones, muddle along together. And its stylistic difference is hard to overstate. “Happy clappy” is a rather inadequate summary: there is also an aura of shiny pro- fessionalism, and steely certainty. This struck me anew when I looked at HTB’s website (that’s Holy Trinity Brompton, home of the Alpha movement). It exudes a slick internationalism, a youthful dynamism; it smells of success. I watched a video in which the church’s married co-leaders chat on stage. It is all very aspirational. Change a few words, and the accents, and we could be at an American business leadership conference. Vaughan Roberts leads an evangelical parish in Oxford, St Ebbe’s. I first heard of him last year, just before Synod’s vote, when he wrote a response to a booklet by his bishop, Steven Croft, in which he advocated gay marriage (almost uniquely for a senior bishop). But to say that Croft is “his bishop” stretches things. For he openly rejects Croft’s spiritual authority over him. Incidentally, Roberts is same-sex attracted, which intensifies his sense of betrayal: the Church now seems to disparage the sacrifice he has made in remaining celibate. The current showdown in the Church of England over sex and marriage has been brewing for at least 30 years, but since same-sex marriage became law in 2014 the crisis has been acute. Can the national Church dissent from a major aspect of national morality? The showdown in The search for a compromise is over, says Roberts. “If we keep trying to meet in the middle we’ ll be fighting over this for years – let’s face reality, cut to the chase.” Separation will be good for liberals, too, he says: “It will also suit those who want to go further with reform – I don’t see how the Church of England over sex and marriage has been brewing for at least 30 years After a five-year consultation process, the Church decided that fuller acceptance of homosexuality was needed, and last year Synod approved blessings for same-sex couples. This was done without the full authorisation (two-thirds majorities in all three houses of Synod) that is needed for major innovations, and with a proviso that the doctrine of marriage won’t be affected. IT IS LITTLE surprise that the evangelicals (and their Anglo-Catholic allies) cried foul, and that the planned reform was partly halted (stand-alone blessings have not quite been signed off, and the archbishops’ new “pastoral guidance”, expected to legitimise gay clergy, has been delayed). The conservatives feel that the Rubicon has been crossed (in a rather underhand way), that the Church’s leadership is now in error, and that they can only stay within the Church if their right to dissent from this error is fully protected. they’re going to be able to do it otherwise, for Synod won’t deliver two- thirds majorities for this reform any time soon.” Doesn’t the unity of the Church of England matter? “I find it extraordinary that those of us who are standing up for what has always been understood as the catholic faith are the ones who are being accused of disunity. I’m not hearing those liberals who are pushing for full inclusion and equal marriage being accused of disunity.” So he really thinks that a separate province for conservatives is possible? “I’m starting with the principle, then we’ ll see what that means in practice. The principle is a structural arrangement that allows distinction within one Church of England.” Why pretend it would still be one Church? “The alternative is a much deeper division – the alternative is winner- 4 | THE TABLET | 18 MAY 2024 For more features, news, analysis and comment, visit www.thetablet.co.uk
page 5
takes-all. If you still have one Church of England, that does allow permeability, engagement, dialogue.” If no such settlement emerges, he might have to move to another denomination. Would that be so bad? “My Anglicanism matters enormously to me – I don’t see anything quite like it in the Christian world. It wouldn’t destroy my faith if I was to leave the Church because my faith is in Christ, not the Church of England, but I would grieve deeply – the national connection is huge – I wouldn’t want to give that up, not just for pragmatic reasons but from deep theological principle – and emotional connection as well.” Roberts’ thinking is in line with that of the Church of England Evangelical Council (CEEC). Long before last year’s vote it started planning for the likelihood of the Church moving in a reformist direction. As early as 2016 it spoke of “visible differentiation” as a likely necessity. This means being fully clear that the “orthodox” grouping rejects the course taken by the rest of the Church, and has its own structures, including bishops. Following last year’s vote, the CEEC launched a couple of initiatives in this direction. It urged “orthodox” churches to pay their diocese’s share into a new kitty, the Ephesian Fund. It also set up a scheme of “alternative spiritual oversight”. The CEEC website explains: “This is a temporary provision which will support evangelicals until a settlement based on structural provision is made available.” A few decades ago, such open disdain for the Church’s official structures was unthinkable; now, it’s almost taken for granted. I SPEAK TO Canon John Dunnett, the CEEC’s national director. He is a friendly but no-nonsense Yorkshireman. I ask him to sum up, in his own words, what the Church agreed to last year. “What we’ve agreed, by a small majority, is to carry the proposals for samesex blessings forward. But we’ve never had a debate about the proper place for sexual intimacy, we’ve not explored the possibility of clergy being able to marry a same-sex partner, and yet that appears to have suddenly jumped up the agenda.” Would he agree that a majority of the Church wants reform? “Well it depends what question you ask. As well as the liberals and the conservatives, there’s a large middle ground who are not represented at Synod. I think a lot of them would say: ‘My instincts are that marriage is for a man and a woman.’ And the vast majority of parish vicars want the issue to go away, they don’t want it to divide their congregations.” If Synod’s reformist majority continues to stabilise or increases a bit, then why should the Church of England agree to CEEC’s proposals about a separate province or whatever? Is that a silly question? “No, it’s a good question. Just to be clear, though, we’ve never said that we want a separate province, it’s one of a range of options that we’ve put on the table. What we are clear about is what the provisions need to be – the shape or packaging is up for discussion. But if the question is: ‘Why should they grant this?’, I suppose the obvious answer is: ‘Because there are some good people among the liberals who don’t want to run the risk of us walking.’ And I think there are some calculating liberals who are thinking: Well, if you look at these evangelical churches that are part of CEEC, it’s all the big ones, it’s all the ones with lots of young people, it’s the ones with big numbers of global heritage people, so it would strike a serious blow at diversity if these churches walked. These are the churches that have planted, and have a lot of resources that are useful. If you’re sitting on a ministry team, you’ ll say these are the churches that have produced ordinands over the years. And if you’re sitting on a bishop’s leadership team, you’ ll say these are the churches that pay the biggest parish share.” And now Dunnett raises another possible solution, if that is the word. “What I have suggested to some of our liberal bishops is that we actually create new space within the Church for those who want to pursue change. In other words, not a space for orthodoxy, but a new space for liberalism. Now they look a bit shocked because they think: But the liberals won the initial vote in Synod, to which I say, ‘Yes’, but you still have to get all this stuff through Synod. So what about a new province for liberals? They could introduce same-sex marriage in parish churches. We could help that get through General Synod. The price they’d pay is that they’d have to leave the default Church of England.” I wonder what conservative bishops are thinking. They are in a small minority: only seven signed a letter earlier this year protesting at the reform process. I speak to one off the record. He advocates much the same thing as Roberts and Dunnett, but in a different tone of voice: calm, accommodating, pragmatic. He almost suggests that there’s nothing to see here, it’s just a fairly normal bit of Anglican muddle, so let’s dial down the rhetoric and try to muddle on nicely. Another conservative bishop is happy to speak on the record. Jill Duff is the frank and friendly Bishop of Lancaster. I expect that she has often been called a breath of fresh air. First I ask her about her formation as an Anglican. Raised in an only slightly religious family in Bolton, she went to a C of E primary school and attended the local evangelical church. As a student she explored other options: the Baptists, and the house church movement, part of the charismatic renewal. As a postgraduate at Oxford she returned to evangelical Anglicanism, and after a spell in the oil industry trained at Wycliffe Hall, where alongside the dominant evangelicalism she sampled more Catholic traditions: contemplative prayer, silent retreats. She has called the introduction of samesex blessings “an error”. Is it such a big error that she feels she can no longer accept the spiritual authority of the archbishops? “No, I’ve not said that. Never said that.” So she would not feel the need to differentiate herself from this error? “One of my heroes is Bishop Selwyn, the great planter of churches in the Polynesian islands, who became Bishop of New Zealand. He said that when you are involved in mission in different cultures, do not get overly concerned about error, because the Church will purify itself as a running stream purifies itself. In my mind, I just want to crack on with mission, and trust that error will get purged away.” IT SOUNDS as if she does not see structural differentiation as an imminent necessity, but when I re-frame the question she gives a different impression: “A lot of evangelicals are wanting a missional eco-system where they can thrive – and Catholics as well. That would allow churches to continue to be planted, and the vocations pipeline – that’s the challenge on the ground.” The “vocations pipeline” is the rather indecorous phrase referring to the need for new evangelical vicars to be trained strictly within their “orthodox” tradition. But if that eco-system becomes more distinct from the rest of the Church, surely unity is threatened? She addresses this by widening the issue, and referring to the Church’s other split, over women’s ordination (which has been addressed by allowing traditionalist parishes to be overseen by traditionalist bishops). “My colleagues who are conservative on that issue represent mainstream views, both internationally and historically. The Church has always been a broad Church, and there’s far more that unites us than divides us.” So she expects CONTINUED ON PAG E 6 Pilgrimage to Patmos 23 - 30 September 2024 Come with us to the beautiful island of Patmos where you can visit the Cave of the Revelation,the Monastery of St John and sites of St John’s visions. Tour Leader: Fr Nicholas King £1,550 per person (sharing) includes: • Accommodation in pretty hotel in Skalatown, easy walking distance to shops and restaurants. • Single supplement £250. • Return fl ights from London to Athens • 7 hour ferry Piraeus to Patmos return • Breakfast and one meal each day (except days of travel) • One night in Athens • Local transport and guides • Entrance to Cave of Revelation, Monastery of St John • Daily Mass, outside where possible • Salt water swimming pool at hotel Contact us on 01886 812 862 or enquiries@jcjourneys.com For more features, news, analysis and comment, visit www.thetablet.co.uk 18 MAY 2024 | THE TABLET | 5

takes-all. If you still have one Church of England, that does allow permeability, engagement, dialogue.”

If no such settlement emerges, he might have to move to another denomination. Would that be so bad? “My Anglicanism matters enormously to me – I don’t see anything quite like it in the Christian world. It wouldn’t destroy my faith if I was to leave the Church because my faith is in Christ, not the Church of England, but I would grieve deeply – the national connection is huge – I wouldn’t want to give that up, not just for pragmatic reasons but from deep theological principle – and emotional connection as well.”

Roberts’ thinking is in line with that of the Church of England Evangelical Council (CEEC). Long before last year’s vote it started planning for the likelihood of the Church moving in a reformist direction. As early as 2016 it spoke of “visible differentiation” as a likely necessity. This means being fully clear that the “orthodox” grouping rejects the course taken by the rest of the Church, and has its own structures, including bishops.

Following last year’s vote, the CEEC launched a couple of initiatives in this direction. It urged “orthodox” churches to pay their diocese’s share into a new kitty, the Ephesian Fund. It also set up a scheme of “alternative spiritual oversight”. The CEEC website explains: “This is a temporary provision which will support evangelicals until a settlement based on structural provision is made available.” A few decades ago, such open disdain for the Church’s official structures was unthinkable; now, it’s almost taken for granted.

I SPEAK TO Canon John Dunnett, the CEEC’s national director. He is a friendly but no-nonsense Yorkshireman. I ask him to sum up, in his own words, what the Church agreed to last year. “What we’ve agreed, by a small majority, is to carry the proposals for samesex blessings forward. But we’ve never had a debate about the proper place for sexual intimacy, we’ve not explored the possibility of clergy being able to marry a same-sex partner, and yet that appears to have suddenly jumped up the agenda.” Would he agree that a majority of the Church wants reform? “Well it depends what question you ask. As well as the liberals and the conservatives, there’s a large middle ground who are not represented at Synod. I think a lot of them would say: ‘My instincts are that marriage is for a man and a woman.’ And the vast majority of parish vicars want the issue to go away, they don’t want it to divide their congregations.”

If Synod’s reformist majority continues to stabilise or increases a bit, then why should the Church of England agree to CEEC’s proposals about a separate province or whatever? Is that a silly question? “No, it’s a good question. Just to be clear, though, we’ve never said that we want a separate province, it’s one of a range of options that we’ve put on the table. What we are clear about is what the provisions need to be – the shape or packaging is up for discussion. But if the question is: ‘Why should they grant this?’, I suppose the obvious answer is: ‘Because there are some good people among the liberals who don’t want to run the risk of us walking.’ And I think there are some calculating liberals who are thinking: Well, if you look at these evangelical churches that are part of CEEC, it’s all the big ones, it’s all the ones with lots of young people, it’s the ones with big numbers of global heritage people, so it would strike a serious blow at diversity if these churches walked. These are the churches that have planted, and have a lot of resources that are useful. If you’re sitting on a ministry team, you’ ll say these are the churches that have produced ordinands over the years. And if you’re sitting on a bishop’s leadership team, you’ ll say these are the churches that pay the biggest parish share.”

And now Dunnett raises another possible solution, if that is the word. “What I have suggested to some of our liberal bishops is that we actually create new space within the Church for those who want to pursue change. In other words, not a space for orthodoxy, but a new space for liberalism. Now they look a bit shocked because they think: But the liberals won the initial vote in Synod, to which I say, ‘Yes’, but you still have to get all this stuff through Synod. So what about a new province for liberals? They could introduce same-sex marriage in parish churches. We could help that get through General Synod. The price they’d pay is that they’d have to leave the default Church of England.”

I wonder what conservative bishops are thinking. They are in a small minority: only seven signed a letter earlier this year protesting at the reform process. I speak to one off the record. He advocates much the same thing as Roberts and Dunnett, but in a different tone of voice: calm, accommodating, pragmatic. He almost suggests that there’s nothing to see here, it’s just a fairly normal bit of Anglican muddle, so let’s dial down the rhetoric and try to muddle on nicely.

Another conservative bishop is happy to speak on the record. Jill Duff is the frank and friendly Bishop of Lancaster. I expect that she has often been called a breath of fresh air. First I ask her about her formation as an Anglican. Raised in an only slightly religious family in Bolton, she went to a C of E primary school and attended the local evangelical church. As a student she explored other options: the Baptists, and the house church movement, part of the charismatic renewal. As a postgraduate at Oxford she returned to evangelical Anglicanism, and after a spell in the oil industry trained at Wycliffe Hall, where alongside the dominant evangelicalism she sampled more Catholic traditions: contemplative prayer, silent retreats.

She has called the introduction of samesex blessings “an error”. Is it such a big error that she feels she can no longer accept the spiritual authority of the archbishops? “No, I’ve not said that. Never said that.” So she would not feel the need to differentiate herself from this error? “One of my heroes is Bishop Selwyn, the great planter of churches in the Polynesian islands, who became Bishop of

New Zealand. He said that when you are involved in mission in different cultures, do not get overly concerned about error, because the Church will purify itself as a running stream purifies itself. In my mind, I just want to crack on with mission, and trust that error will get purged away.”

IT SOUNDS as if she does not see structural differentiation as an imminent necessity, but when I re-frame the question she gives a different impression: “A lot of evangelicals are wanting a missional eco-system where they can thrive – and Catholics as well. That would allow churches to continue to be planted, and the vocations pipeline – that’s the challenge on the ground.” The “vocations pipeline” is the rather indecorous phrase referring to the need for new evangelical vicars to be trained strictly within their “orthodox” tradition.

But if that eco-system becomes more distinct from the rest of the Church, surely unity is threatened? She addresses this by widening the issue, and referring to the Church’s other split, over women’s ordination (which has been addressed by allowing traditionalist parishes to be overseen by traditionalist bishops). “My colleagues who are conservative on that issue represent mainstream views, both internationally and historically. The Church has always been a broad Church, and there’s far more that unites us than divides us.” So she expects

CONTINUED ON PAG E 6

Pilgrimage to Patmos

23 - 30 September 2024

Come with us to the beautiful island of Patmos where you can visit the Cave of the Revelation,the Monastery of St John and

sites of St John’s visions. Tour Leader: Fr Nicholas King

£1,550 per person (sharing) includes: • Accommodation in pretty hotel in

Skalatown, easy walking distance to shops and restaurants. • Single supplement £250. • Return fl ights from London to Athens • 7 hour ferry Piraeus to Patmos return • Breakfast and one meal each day (except

days of travel) • One night in Athens • Local transport and guides • Entrance to Cave of Revelation,

Monastery of St John • Daily Mass, outside where possible • Salt water swimming pool at hotel

Contact us on 01886 812 862 or enquiries@jcjourneys.com

For more features, news, analysis and comment, visit www.thetablet.co.uk

18 MAY 2024 | THE TABLET | 5

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content