Skip to main content
Read page text
page 4
FEATURES / Religion and politics Though several prominent Christian politicians lost their seats in the July election and barely a half of MPs swore their oath of allegiance on the Bible, the House of Commons is more religiously rich and diverse than ever / By ABIGAIL FRYMANN ROUCH In the House of God AFTER A SUMMER scarred by racist riots, MPs returned to the House of Commons this week. A few more than half of them, 335 out of 635, are newcomers, elected only weeks before the recess in July. The changes to the make-up of the House have been much commented on: in addition to a general shift to the left, MPs are more racially diverse (14 per cent from ethnic minorities, according to the thinktank British Future, up from 10 per cent after the 2019 election), there are more women (40 per cent, up from 34 per cent in 2019), and nearly two-thirds of MPs attended a comprehensive school (63 per cent, up from 54 per cent), according to the social mobility charity, the Sutton Trust. The Commons is now more religiously diverse, thanks to an increase in the number of Muslims, Jews, Hindus and Sikhs, though you might not realise it at first. The campaigning group Humanists UK counted how many MPs chose to swear their allegiance to the King by God, and on which holy book, and how many opted instead to make a secular affirmation of that allegiance. Forty per cent of MPs chose to affirm, up from 24 per cent in 2019. These included the prime minister Sir Keir Starmer and half the cabinet. Only a slim majority – 338 of 625 – swore their oath of allegiance on the Bible, mainly the King James version, though commentators noted that a number asked for the King Charles, the King George, the King Edward or the St James version. “Just under 6 per cent of MPs gave oaths which indicated they belonged to Muslim, Jewish, Hindu, or Sikh religious traditions. This is broadly representative of society as a whole,” said Humanists UK, which concluded that the UK had “elected the most openly non-religious House of Commons in history” – or, as The Times headline had it, “the most godless”. The social scientist Francis Davis, a vice chair of the Catholic Union, believes the Humanists’ analysis “represents a sloppy and partial sociology of religion … ‘ belief ’ or a ‘simple text’ alone does not designate belonging, participation, family relationships or the range of convictions that make up the diversity of lived religious life”. Humanists UK estimates the proportion of Catholic MPs to be 7 per cent. Davis believes the actual number to be “substantially more than 35”, but as he observed, not all MPs wear their religious affiliation on their sleeve. Among those who do, there has been some significant changes. Gone are former ministers including Catholics Thérèse Coffey, Jacob Rees-Mogg, Damian Green and Maria PHOTOS: ALAMY/PA/UK PARLIAMENT, MATT ALEXANDER, STEFAN ROUSSEAU, RUSSELL HART Clockwise, from top left: Green Party leader and ‘non-theist’ Quaker, Carla Denyer; Labour’s Jewish solicitor general Sarah Sackman; Conservative MP and Muslim former minister Nusrat Ghani; Catholic-educated Hindu and new Labour MP, Uma Kumaran Caulfield. Prominent Conservative Christian MPs to have left Parliament include Miriam Cates and Fiona Bruce, the Special Envoy for Freedom of Religion or Belief, who worked with the crossbench Catholic peer Lord Alton. KEIR STARMER’s Cabinet includes two Catholics: Pat McFadden, Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, and Bridget Phillipson, Education Secretary and Minister for Women and Equalities, who replaces the Catholiceducated Gillian Keegan. Both attended Catholic comprehensives, in Glasgow and Sunderland respectively. Then there are two junior ministers: Aviation Minister Mike Kane, the founder of Catholics for Labour, and the School Standards Minister Catherine McKinnell, a former chair of Cafod’s All-Party Parliamentary Group, and one of four women MPs educated at a Sacred Heart school (hers was in Newcastle). The Cabinet also includes Foreign Secretary David Lammy, a former chorister at Peterborough Cathedral who has spoken of his “deep faith”; Health Secretary Wes Streeting, who has said he has “agonised” over being Christian and gay, and Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, who was until the election the chair of Christians on the Left (CotL), another ecumenical group. Reynolds worships in an Anglican church when home in Greater Manchester, and at the pro-LGBT Oasis Church Waterloo when in London. Hannah Rich, CotL’s director, tells me all three are members of her organisation, along with Catherine McKinnell and other junior ministers including Sir Stephen Timms, Social Security and Disability Minister. Veteran Liberal Democrat MP – and former leader of the party – Tim Farron believes the number of practising Christians in this Parliament is about the same. “I can think of at least three, I think it might be four, new Lib Dem MPs who are Christians. I’ ll not out them,” he told me, smiling. “That’s up to them.” He puts the drop in the number of MPs 4 | THE TABLET | 7 SEPTEMBER 2024 For more features, news, analysis and comment, visit www.thetablet.co.uk
page 5
swearing on the Bible down to the collapse in nominal Christianity. Many new MPs are from a younger generation “for whom church attendance is not even a thing that’s happened in the last two generations of their families”. Farron himself opted to affirm rather than swear on the Bible after reflecting – in the queue of MPs – on Christ’s words in Matthew (“Let your word be ‘Yes, Yes’ or ‘No, No’; anything more than this comes from the evil one”). Catherine West (a former patron of Hong Kong Watch), and Ruth Cadbury (a descendant of the confectioners and social reformers), are both Labour. Carla Denyer (co-leader of the Green Party) is the first Quaker MP to lead a parliamentary party. She has described herself as a “nontheist” Quaker, motivated by Teresa of Ávila’s words, “God has no hands but ours.” Different political affiliation is likely to mean different priorities, even if those priorities flow from the same faith. David Burrowes, a former Conservative MP and co-founder of the ecumenical Conservative Christian Fellowship, said that since the election the number of MPs engaged with the CCF had fallen from 30-40 to “up to 10”. He said he felt “the loss of champions of Christian causes” such as conscience issues and life issues, naming Caulfield, Coffey, Cates and Bruce. “We’ ll see how [the new MPs] are able to handle some of those conscience issues, where, in past experience, it’s been harder for Christian Labour and Liberal Democrat MPs to be campaigning.” He said that when he was elected in 2005, the then-Labour government was “hostile to issues of freedom of speech and conscience”. THE NUMBER of Muslim MPs has risen from 19 to 26; the number of Tories among them has halved to just two – Nusrat Ghani and Saqib Bhatti. Most are Labour, though four are pro-Palestine independents who took previously Labour-held seats. Muhammad Abdul Bari, former secretary general of the Muslim Council of Britain, told me that younger, politically conscious, social-media literate Muslims wanted to send the message that “business should not be as usual”. Of the four independents, he said: “At least they don’t have any whip to control them. They can say whatever they like.” Hashim Bhatti, national chair of the Conservative Muslim Forum, countered: “It would be interesting to see, when the dust settles on the conflict in the Middle East, whether they can still galvanise grassroots supporters in those areas on domestic issues.” He told me that four pro-Gaza independents could do little “to shift the debate or even push their own agenda”. For many MPs, their identity comprises a shifting blend of affiliations and Hannah Rich told me that around 50 MPs were members of Christians on the Left, many with “backgrounds in the charity sector or in international development or in local voluntary action, often through their church”. One issue of concern was the two-child limit on social security payments. She said conscience and life issues were priorities for “some” of their members, and that CotL would be responding to the assisted dying legislation on which Keir Starmer has promised a free vote “as and when it arises”. traditions Priorities for the Catholic Union, though considered Tory-leaning in recent years, now straddle the political divide. “We have already had strong interest in proposed legislation to reform the Mental Health Act, and additional interest regarding protecting overseas aid and repealing the two-child cap,” Davis tells me, adding: “Our President, Baroness Hollins, has a long-standing interest in not putting at risk vulnerable people by the introduction of unworkable assisted dying laws.” Farron lists three issues he hopes Christian MPs can unite around: opposing assisted dying, taking a “more compassionate view” towards refugees, and “tackling the evils of conversion therapy” in a way “that doesn’t lump in absolutely legitimate Bible teaching and pastoral support”. He adds: “How people divide on these issues will depend upon how mindful the new government is … of the need to be genuine defenders of diversity and liberty.” Andrew Gilbert, a vice-president of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, described the change among Jewish MPs as “massive”. Gilbert, who also chairs a committee of the Jewish Labour Movement, said that while Jewish MPs would not be likely to vote as a bloc, on Israel the Jewish voice in Parliament had undergone “a significant move leftward” which would put most of the Jewish Labour MPs “at the centre-right of the Labour Party on Israel”, meaning they would be likely to “endorse a two-state solution” and would be “sometimes critical of Israel … constructively”. He added: “None of this group will have any truck with the current prime minister of Israel.” Before July there had been eight Conservative and only six Jewish Labour MPs, reflecting, Gilbert said, antisemitism in the Labour party as well as changing constituency demographics. Now, of the 16 Jewish MPs, most are Labour; only one is Conservative, Julian Lewis. Gone are Grant Shapps, the former defence secretary, and Sir Michael Fabricant; two of the new Jewish MPs are already ministers: Sarah Sackman, solicitorgeneral, and Georgia Gould, parliamentary secretary for the Cabinet Office. Gilbert told me Keir Starmer’s family is “very influenced by [his wife] Victoria’s Jewish background … they’re connected to the liberal side [of Judaism]”. Rather than push specific issues, the Quaker writer and journalist Jill Segger suggested that the six Quaker MPs will try to bring values of peace, equality and truth into Commons debates. The two MPs re-elected, Gilbert’s observation about the prime minister’s home life raises an aspect of religion that defies simple arithmetic: for many MPs, as for many people in contemporary Britain, their identity comprises a shifting blend of affiliations and traditions. Uma Kumaran, the new MP for the ethnically and religiously diverse constituency of Stratford and Bow, is a Tamil Hindu. Her parents fled Sri Lanka in the civil war; the Hinduism she and her parents practise co-exists easily with Catholicism. She tells me her parents proudly attended Catholic schools in Sri Lanka and she went to a Catholic sixth form in Harrowon-the-Hill. Through her work for a climate charity, she attended a conference in the Vatican earlier this year. When she realised she would be meeting the Pope she messaged her parents. Her mother, via a family friend, swiftly managed to contact the Bishop of Jaffna, Justin Gnanapragasam, and she was able to convey to Francis greetings from the diocese’s celebrated shrine of Our Lady of Madhu, a place sacred to many Tamils and which provided shelter to thousands of them in the civil war. Kumaran believes all religions encourage people to love their neighbours and care for the planet. Her husband is a “white workingclass boy from Wales” with Catholic and Protestant roots. “There’s such love between our families,” she told me. “Our differences are something to be celebrated. Perhaps it’s easier for me as a brown woman to say these things than it is for some other politicians.” Kumaran is one of 11 Hindu or Hindu- CONTINUED ON PAG E 6 For more features, news, analysis and comment, visit www.thetablet.co.uk 7 SEPTEMBER 2024 | THE TABLET | 5

swearing on the Bible down to the collapse in nominal Christianity. Many new MPs are from a younger generation “for whom church attendance is not even a thing that’s happened in the last two generations of their families”. Farron himself opted to affirm rather than swear on the Bible after reflecting – in the queue of MPs – on Christ’s words in Matthew (“Let your word be ‘Yes, Yes’ or ‘No, No’; anything more than this comes from the evil one”).

Catherine West (a former patron of Hong Kong Watch), and Ruth Cadbury (a descendant of the confectioners and social reformers), are both Labour. Carla Denyer (co-leader of the Green Party) is the first Quaker MP to lead a parliamentary party. She has described herself as a “nontheist” Quaker, motivated by Teresa of Ávila’s words, “God has no hands but ours.”

Different political affiliation is likely to mean different priorities, even if those priorities flow from the same faith. David Burrowes, a former Conservative MP and co-founder of the ecumenical Conservative Christian Fellowship, said that since the election the number of MPs engaged with the CCF had fallen from 30-40 to “up to 10”. He said he felt “the loss of champions of Christian causes” such as conscience issues and life issues, naming Caulfield, Coffey, Cates and Bruce. “We’ ll see how [the new MPs] are able to handle some of those conscience issues, where, in past experience, it’s been harder for Christian Labour and Liberal Democrat MPs to be campaigning.” He said that when he was elected in 2005, the then-Labour government was “hostile to issues of freedom of speech and conscience”.

THE NUMBER of Muslim MPs has risen from 19 to 26; the number of Tories among them has halved to just two – Nusrat Ghani and Saqib Bhatti. Most are Labour, though four are pro-Palestine independents who took previously Labour-held seats. Muhammad Abdul Bari, former secretary general of the Muslim Council of Britain, told me that younger, politically conscious, social-media literate Muslims wanted to send the message that “business should not be as usual”. Of the four independents, he said: “At least they don’t have any whip to control them. They can say whatever they like.” Hashim Bhatti, national chair of the Conservative Muslim Forum, countered: “It would be interesting to see, when the dust

settles on the conflict in the Middle East, whether they can still galvanise grassroots supporters in those areas on domestic issues.” He told me that four pro-Gaza independents could do little “to shift the debate or even push their own agenda”.

For many MPs,

their identity

comprises a shifting blend of affiliations and

Hannah Rich told me that around 50 MPs were members of Christians on the Left, many with “backgrounds in the charity sector or in international development or in local voluntary action, often through their church”. One issue of concern was the two-child limit on social security payments. She said conscience and life issues were priorities for “some” of their members, and that CotL would be responding to the assisted dying legislation on which Keir Starmer has promised a free vote “as and when it arises”.

traditions

Priorities for the Catholic Union, though considered Tory-leaning in recent years, now straddle the political divide. “We have already had strong interest in proposed legislation to reform the Mental Health Act, and additional interest regarding protecting overseas aid and repealing the two-child cap,” Davis tells me, adding: “Our President, Baroness Hollins, has a long-standing interest in not putting at risk vulnerable people by the introduction of unworkable assisted dying laws.”

Farron lists three issues he hopes Christian MPs can unite around: opposing assisted dying, taking a “more compassionate view” towards refugees, and “tackling the evils of conversion therapy” in a way “that doesn’t lump in absolutely legitimate Bible teaching and pastoral support”. He adds: “How people divide on these issues will depend upon how mindful the new government is … of the need to be genuine defenders of diversity and liberty.”

Andrew Gilbert, a vice-president of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, described the

change among Jewish MPs as “massive”. Gilbert, who also chairs a committee of the Jewish Labour Movement, said that while Jewish MPs would not be likely to vote as a bloc, on Israel the Jewish voice in Parliament had undergone “a significant move leftward” which would put most of the Jewish Labour MPs “at the centre-right of the Labour Party on Israel”, meaning they would be likely to “endorse a two-state solution” and would be “sometimes critical of Israel … constructively”. He added: “None of this group will have any truck with the current prime minister of Israel.”

Before July there had been eight Conservative and only six Jewish Labour MPs, reflecting, Gilbert said, antisemitism in the Labour party as well as changing constituency demographics. Now, of the 16 Jewish MPs, most are Labour; only one is Conservative, Julian Lewis. Gone are Grant Shapps, the former defence secretary, and Sir Michael Fabricant; two of the new Jewish MPs are already ministers: Sarah Sackman, solicitorgeneral, and Georgia Gould, parliamentary secretary for the Cabinet Office. Gilbert told me Keir Starmer’s family is “very influenced by [his wife] Victoria’s Jewish background … they’re connected to the liberal side [of Judaism]”.

Rather than push specific issues, the Quaker writer and journalist Jill Segger suggested that the six Quaker MPs will try to bring values of peace, equality and truth into Commons debates. The two MPs re-elected,

Gilbert’s observation about the prime minister’s home life raises an aspect of religion that defies simple arithmetic: for many MPs, as for many people in contemporary Britain, their identity comprises a shifting blend of affiliations and traditions. Uma Kumaran, the new MP for the ethnically and religiously diverse constituency of Stratford and Bow, is a Tamil Hindu. Her parents fled Sri Lanka in the civil war; the Hinduism she and her parents practise co-exists easily with Catholicism. She tells me her parents proudly attended Catholic schools in Sri Lanka and she went to a Catholic sixth form in Harrowon-the-Hill. Through her work for a climate charity, she attended a conference in the Vatican earlier this year. When she realised she would be meeting the Pope she messaged her parents. Her mother, via a family friend, swiftly managed to contact the Bishop of Jaffna, Justin Gnanapragasam, and she was able to convey to Francis greetings from the diocese’s celebrated shrine of Our Lady of Madhu, a place sacred to many Tamils and which provided shelter to thousands of them in the civil war.

Kumaran believes all religions encourage people to love their neighbours and care for the planet. Her husband is a “white workingclass boy from Wales” with Catholic and Protestant roots. “There’s such love between our families,” she told me. “Our differences are something to be celebrated. Perhaps it’s easier for me as a brown woman to say these things than it is for some other politicians.”

Kumaran is one of 11 Hindu or Hindu-

CONTINUED ON PAG E 6

For more features, news, analysis and comment, visit www.thetablet.co.uk

7 SEPTEMBER 2024 | THE TABLET | 5

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content