Analytics Consent

We use analytics to understand better how people are using this site.

Permit Google Analytics?

Yes No
Skip to main content
Read page text
page 6
Unsplash+ Unsplash+ Unsplash+ Unsplash+ Unsplash+ THE ALCHEMY OF HOPE: FROM DESPAIR TO RENEWAL IN COACHING AND LEADERSHIP Hope isn't a concept we think into existence, says Simon Goland. It is a physiological state we return to when safety, connection, and aliveness are restored. WHEN HOPE FEELS FAR AWAY I once sat across from a senior executive whose résumé could have doubled as a corporate legend. But that day, something had broken open in her. She stared at the table, eyes clouded, and said quietly, 'I don't know if what I do matters any more.' It wasn't burnout or depression. It was that heavy, silent despaircousin of exhaustion that creeps in when purpose feels like a myth we once believed. Without hope, our work as coaches, leaders, and supervisors loses its vital spark the animating current that keeps us oriented toward life rather than away from it In moments like these, the word hope can sound almost naive. What use is hope when glaciers are melting, geopolitical chaos seems to be on steroids, organisations are restructuring for the fifth time this year, and the most common phrase in boardrooms is 'doing more with less?' And yet, without hope, our work as coaches, leaders, and supervisors loses its vital the animating current that keeps us oriented sparktoward life rather than away from it. HOPE BEYOND POSITIVITY Hope, as I have come to understand, is not an emotion or an outcome. It is a practice. It is a posture of the body and spirit that allows us to keep engaging with what is difficult without collapsing into cynicism or false optimism. In my early years as a coach, I unconsciously treated hope as a kind of performance enhancer. It was the energetic fuel for reaching goals, achieving targets, crafting shiny visions of success. We had formulas for SMART goals, accountability structures, 360 feedback. Hope everythingwas the background music to a culture obsessed with forward motion. But as coaching evolved, so did my understanding. Hope is not the same as positivity. The former requires courage; the latter often avoids discomfort. Hope, when embodied, is not an escape from despair but a willingness to sit beside to breathe, listen, and wait for the next itright movement to reveal itself. The opposite of despair isn't blind hope. It is embodied presence. THE SOMATIC GROUND OF HOPE I once worked with a CEO who was brilliant, strategic, and perpetually exhausted. She described feeling as though she was 'carrying the company on her back.' Her body told the story long before her mind caught up, with hunched shoulders, a jaw perpetually clenched, breath that rarely travelled below the collarbones. We explored this state through somatic presence, inquiry, and awareness. As she softened, her breath deepened, colour returned to her face, and she whispered, 'I feel hopeful. For no reason.' The opposite of despair isn't blind hope. It is embodied presence. That moment reminded me that hope is not an idea we think into existence. It is a physiological state we return to when safety, connection, and aliveness are restored. 6 associationforcoaching.com
page 7
Neuroscience confirms what our wise bodies have always known: hope begins below the neck. The vagus that wandering bridge nervebetween gut, heart, and carries most of its messages upward, brainfrom body to mind, not the other way around. Which means that the stories we tell ourselves about the future are profoundly shaped by the state of our nervous system in the present. When we are in a sympathetic mobilised for action, braced state for our world view naturally contracts. Hope feels far away survivalbecause our biology is doing its job, protecting us from threat. When we collapse into dorsal parasympathetic shutdown, the body's energy drops, our breath flattens, and even imagining possibility feels impossible. It is not a mindset problem; it is a physiological state of our being. True hope emerges when we come home to the ventral vagal state, which is that place of grounded safety where body and heart remember connection. In this state, curiosity returns. Our gaze lifts. We can feel others again. The future begins to shimmer with faint possibility. This is why we cannot think or will our way from despair to hope. No amount of re-framing, affirmations, or positive thinking can override a nervous system that doesn't feel safe. We must work through and with the through breath, through presence and grounding, bodythrough gentle co-regulation with another human being who can hold presence when ours falters. True hope emerges when we come home to the ventral vagal state, which is that place of grounded safety where body and heart remember connection Hope, then, is not a motivational speech. It is the nervous system remembering safety after fear, the heart remembering connection after isolation, the lungs remembering to exhale after holding too much for too long. It is not fragile or abstract. It is biological, a natural rhythm that returns whenever we stop trying to control, fix, or transcend our humanity and instead inhabit it fully. When we begin to see hope as a somatic process rather than an emotional luxury, we start to understand why some of the most hopeful people are not the ones shouting optimism from the rooftops, but those who know how to pause, breathe, and stay present in the middle of uncertainty. HOPE IN RELATIONSHIP: THE ENNEAGRAM AND THE HUMAN PATTERN One of the most illuminating frameworks I have found for exploring hope and despair (as well as pretty much anything else relevant to human development and awakening) is the Enneagram, as a living mirror for how we habitually lose and rediscover our core essence. At its heart, the Enneagram is a map of remembrance. It describes nine ways we human beings forget who we truly are, and the nine pathways to come home to our essence. Each type represents a particular flavour of disconnection, a specific strategy for surviving a world that once felt too much. For us coaches, it is important to realise that the Enneagram is not about self-improvement in its deepest purpose. It really is about self-liberation. The Enneagram doesn't ask, 'How can I become a better version of my personality?' It asks, 'What would remain if I stopped organising my life around my personality's fears?' Hope is biological, a natural rhythm that returns whenever we stop trying to control, fix, or transcend our humanity and instead inhabit it fully When viewed through this lens, the Enneagram becomes a luminous compass for navigating despair. It reveals the precise moment where hope disappears, be it the subtle contraction, the loss of contact with presence, the movement away from the heart. Yet, it also shows how hope is restored, by relaxing the structures that obscure what is already here, present within the client, the leader, and the coach. In the Enneagram, each type, in its own way, forgets hope: Type 1 loses hope when the world refuses to be perfect. Type 2, when love feels conditional. Type 3, when success stops delivering worth. Type 4, when beauty turns melancholic. Type 5, when knowledge fails to provide safety. Type 6, when trust feels foolish. Type 7, when pleasure loses its shine. Type 8, when control doesn't protect (decades of experience for me personally with this one). Type 9, when peace demands conflict. But within each Enneagram type lies the seed of hope's restoration. As a Type 8 myself, I lose hope when I mistake tenderness for weakness. Hope returns when I soften, which is when power and vulnerability are invited to coexist. For a Type 6, hope may emerge through embodied trust, when the person opens to a somatically sensed and felt evidence that the world is not only dangerous. For a Type 4, hope is rediscovered in the quiet beauty of washing dishes and ordinarinessbeing enough without needing to be special. A Type 4 client once told me, through tears, 'I am scared there is nothing underneath.' Minutes later, she added, almost surprised, 'But this nothing. feels alive.' That is the return of quiet, cellular, real. hope- Hope that excludes despair becomes brittle. Hope that includes it becomes unbreakable. THE SHADOW OF FALSE HOPE Coaches and leaders, by nature, are merchants of hope. We help people believe change is possible. But there is danger when hope becomes performance, when we use it to bypass pain rather than be transformed by it. False hope sounds like this: LEADERSHIP 'It will all work out.' 'Everything happens for a reason.' 'Just stay positive.' These phrases, though well-intentioned, often silence the deeper truth trying to surface. Authentic hope doesn't deny despair; it metabolises it. As coaches, we must ask ourselves: are we offering hope as medicine or as distraction? Are we holding the tension long enough for something real to emerge, or rushing to fix discomfort because we can't bear it? January 2026 | Issue 48 7

Page Text

View plaintext

Hope isn't a concept we think into existence, says Simon Goland. It is a physiological state we return to when safety, connection, and aliveness are restored.

WHEN HOPE FEELS FAR AWAY

I once sat across from a senior executive whose résumé could have doubled as a corporate legend. But that day, something had broken open in her. She stared at the table, eyes clouded, and said quietly, 'I don't know if what I do matters any more.'

It wasn't burnout or depression. It was despair- that heavy, silent cousin of exhaustion that creeps in when purpose feels like a myth we once believed.

Without hope, our work as coaches, leaders, and supervisors loses its vital spark - the animating current that keeps us oriented toward life rather than away from it

In moments like these, the word hope can sound almost naive. What use is hope when glaciers are melting, geopolitical chaos seems to be on steroids, organisations are restructuring for the fifth time this year, and the most common phrase in boardrooms is 'doing more with less?'

And yet, without hope, our work as coaches, leaders, and supervisors loses its vital spark- the animating current that keeps us oriented toward life rather than away from it.

HOPE BEYOND POSITIVITY

Hope, as I have come to understand, is not an emotion or an outcome. It is a practice. It is a posture of the body and spirit that allows us to keep engaging with what is difficult without collapsing into cynicism or false optimism.

In my early years as a coach, I unconsciously treated hope as a kind of performance enhancer. It was the energetic fuel for reaching goals, achieving targets, crafting shiny visions of success. We had formulas for everything- SMART goals, accountability structures, 360 feedback. Hope was the background music to a culture obsessed with forward motion.

But as coaching evolved, so did my understanding. Hope is not the same as positivity. The former requires courage; the latter often avoids discomfort. Hope, when embodied, is not an escape from despair but a willingness to sit beside it- to breathe, listen, and wait for the next right movement to reveal itself.

The opposite of despair isn't blind hope. It is embodied presence.

THE SOMATIC GROUND OF HOPE

I once worked with a CEO who was brilliant, strategic, and perpetually exhausted. She described feeling as though she was 'carrying the company on her back.' Her body told the story long before her mind caught up, with hunched shoulders, a jaw perpetually clenched, breath that rarely travelled below the collarbones.

We explored this state through somatic presence, inquiry, and awareness. As she softened, her breath deepened, colour returned to her face, and she whispered, 'I feel hopeful. For no reason.'

The opposite of despair isn't blind hope. It is embodied presence.

That moment reminded me that hope is not an idea we think into existence. It is a physiological state we return to when safety, connection, and aliveness are restored.

Unsplash+ Unsplash+ Unsplash+ Unsplash+ Unsplash+ THE ALCHEMY OF HOPE: FROM DESPAIR TO RENEWAL IN COACHING AND LEADERSHIP

Read next page

My Bookmarks

Buy this Book
Skip to main content