> FEATURES 02
PERCENTAGE OF WORD COUNT
0.309
0.527
0.457
0.287
0.408
0.382
0.093 WRITER
0.253
0.313
0.135
0.229
0.061
0.244
This feature came out of a conversation about the ease of writing a negative review, compared to a positive one, and the rumination that this might lie in the English language: a preferable or wider vocabulary for the damning over the laudatory, perhaps. After scrutinising the review section of this issue prior to publication, however, I noticed that, in fact, it is sometimes rather difficult to discern if a review is positive or negative. It seems that the dialogical context of Art Monthly – in which justification is required for claim and counterclaim – muffles declarative language. In place of the straightforward use of superlatives or even adjectives, it seems that writers favour the marquetry of metaphors and similes to convey an image and an exposition of that image all at once. Often a text is so infused with metaphorical linguistic expressions that it is difficult to separate the literal from the figurative. Metaphor is descriptive writing off-road, invoking a tangible phenomenon to discuss something more abstract, and many writers employ it at the crucial moment – often in or near the final sentence. Like looking at the eclipse in a bucket of water, the critical event is to be looked at askance. So, a scale might be drawn, with mimetic description at one end and the opinionated rant at the other. While one sample of writing would follow the form of an artwork, the other draws the artwork towards it, effectively sieving it through its own mesh. What is surprising, however, is the scarcity of either extreme. Without wanting to sound defensive – and I agree that there are many, many problems with art criticism at the moment – it does not hold true that we are, in the majority, merely descriptive. Perhaps the accusation should be
redrafted to take into account our metaphorical constructions that engulf artworks and sweep them away on hyperbolic waves of our own conjuring. ❚
NOTES ON THE STATISTICS The key denotes four operative modes of a sentence or subclause: DESCRIPTIVE (Desc), CONTEXTUALISING (Cont), INTERPRETATIVE (Int) and AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL/OPINION (Opin/Auto). By descriptive, I mean passages that convey what an artwork looks like, how it is arranged or some other factual aspect of the exhibition. Any description that also involves an exegesis of the artwork – an evaluation of how it is perceived, an exploration of its themes, the consequences of its effects, and so on – has been included in the interpretative category. Contextualising is defined here as any discussion of art history, critical theory, politics and so on that, although not intrinsic to the artwork or exhibition, adds to an understanding of it. This also includes discussion of previous work by the same artist, which is infrequent, as the show under review is generally prioritised. The conflation of opinion and autobiography is necessary so that, in many cases, either modes of writing would register at all. It is interesting that the unsubstantiated pronouncement of greatness or otherwise is as rare as the self-indulgent. The only time anyone comes close to this is JJ Charlesworth’s ‘brilliant’, which he attaches to the comedian Simon Munnery, and has nothing whatsoever to do with the exhibition under discussion. The belletrist autobiographical style seems to be out of vogue too (for a discussion on this see Alex Coles, ‘The Bathroom Critic’, in AM263.) There are instances when the above classifications were ambiguous. For instance, Alex Farquharson’s interpretation of the work in ‘Los Angeles 1955-1985’ could very well be considered art historical contextualisation – a distinction that also blurs when artworks are steeped in art historical references. Statistics are notoriously subjective and here some categorisations may well be disputable. The figures below the X-axis are the description coefficients of each writer. This value is arrived at by dividing the word count of purely descriptive passages by the overall word count and is expressed in the graph in percentage form by the black bars. SALLY O’REILLY is a writer and critic and co-editor of Implicasphere.
5.06 / ART MONTHLY / 296
9