Skip to main content
Read page text
page 4
Defining Sculpture I am continually reading the opinion that sculpture is no longer a definable art form. This view is, I suppose, a true reflection of the enormous variety of forms that now exist and claim to be sculpture. I f any new sculpture is praised because of how different it is from any other, then eventually the difference in form between one sculptor's work and another will be invented by the artist as a major part of the creative act. This is particularly so at a time of artists as 'professional individuals', guarding their identities by the difference in the form of their work. This could logically lead to dispersal away from any 'sculptural language', and into an ever increasing variety of singular statements in other languages. (The analogy with language is a difficult one, as it implies an equal and complete communication between people. Instead I am using it to refer to the distinct separate sensory system used by an artist to make expression manifest. Therefore with my analogy there would be an aural language of music , a pictorial and visual language of painting, and of course the use of real language as an expressive art form in the language of poetry and literature. As such I cannot find a more convenient analogous form; therefore despite t he risk of appearing a 'formalist'I shall continue to use it.) Without a multitude of sculptors all endeavouring to employ and extend a sculptural language, no language will ever be fully available, and sculpture will not reach a state of complete articulation, where the full range of human expression is possible.: A few years ago, my own sculpture emerged from what I see, in retrospect , to be an eight year long detour. This event has no relevance here, except for one simple aspect; I was able to note that moment of emergence. I self-consciously realised for the first time in over eight years, that I was again using the traditional sculptures that I was looking at in museums and galleries, not just to gain connoisseurship, but to find out how and why the sculptures 'worked' as visual objects, in order that I might use that information to help my own sculpture-making. This meant abandoning the pastime of approaching the sculptures I preferred, and pleasurably 'feasting' before moving on to the next. Instead I tried to scrutinize every part o f the object, and not leave it until I understood (or knew I didn't understand) why it looked as it did, why the parts and forms were as and where they were. How, in fact, I was able to grasp the realness of the object through simply looking at it. This self-inflicted analytic looking certainly removed any idea of idly 'tasting' t he preferred works, in fact sculptures 'liked' or 'disliked' could equally be used in this search for information about my ability to understand these visual objects. (It always seems somewhat conceited that the objects in our museums are 'on trial' rather than our understanding of them.) The only way it's possible to 'read' a sculpture in this way is to understand a sculptural language. If there is a language common to all sculpture ever made, which can help us to see how and why the object looks as it does, this should be an important implement in any search for a definition o f sculpture now. WILLIAM PYE SCULPTURE IN WINCHESTER MAIN EXHIBITION I AUGUST .. 29 SEPTEMBER GREAT HALL &GREAT COURTYARD 4 TABLE SCULPTURES 9 JULY N 2 SEPTEMBER CITY MUSEUM ยท THE SQUARE JOHN HOYLAND PAINTINGS 1967-1979 SERPENTINE GALLERY KENSINGTON GARDENSLONDON W 2 29 September- 28 October 1979 Open dail y 10-6 Ad mission free Arts Cruncil O F G REA T BR IT A I N
page 5
Before looking across the contemporary landscape, peppered as it is with this great variety of forms, I am, for a moment, going to look exclusively at sculptures from previous traditions (which I am referring to as traditional sculpture). For the purpose of making my point more clearly, I am particularly referring to those traditions where sculpture developed as a somewhat self-conscious activity, where objective aesthetic decisions played a great part in moving the sculptural evolution onward. Rather than those more primitive traditions where one has to search in an anthropological area, outside of the sculpture, to find the reason for some of the symbols and forms. Every tradition has its own particularness that makes such generalisations risky, and some traditions such as, say, Egyptian sculpture, are both useful, in the sophisticated aesthetic behind t he sculpture, and also unhelpful as the religious and mystic restrictions prevented any easily observed evolutionary movement. However, I am looking at the objects we have in front of our eyes now; the society they grew in no longer exists with them. Such regard for the selfcontainedness of the objects and their realness, could by myopic, were it not for the fact that there is a set of constant recurring 'devices' in all sculpture that 53 Heol Siarl, Caerdydd CF1 4ED tel. 395548 53 Charles Street, Cardiff CF1 4ED tel. 395548 Harry Snook reliefs September 6-29 A Scottish Arts Council / Welsh Arts Council touring exhibition in conjunctton with The Association of Illustrators Open Monday-Friday 9.30-6.00; Saturday 9.30-5.30 move across traditions and are developed each time by the makers of the sculpture for the same visual reasons. T.S. Elliot proposed that the whole of art ever made forms a constant living 'lump'.The works already forming this 'lump',alter, depending on relevance, to accomodate new arrivals. Thus Greek sculpture changes somewhat as each later sculpture that refers to it is made. There are only old or dead societies; the art they produced is alive and constant, as long as we can understand it and use it. Certainly the British Museum isn't a history lesson for sculptors, all the objects in it are outside of any context or time, and have a selfcontained life given to them by their relevant usefulness in a continual understanding of sculpture. A free-standing traditional sculpture belongs to a quite different art form to that of a painting or a relief sculpture. It is an expressive man-made object in the real world that is exclusively available through its visual appearance. Its presence in the world is real and can be appreciated by bumping into it, but that is not its true reality, or the reality it exists for. It has a three-dimensional reality as a credible object, which is entirely held in its visual sculptural language. Its own visual description of itself as an object, through its forms and devices, gives it this true reality, and puts it firmly into the species, or family of objects, called Sculpture. It is not a replication of any other item or phenomenon from the real world. Although it may approach and allude to other objects, it always remains essentially different from them. If it trespasses too near in its mimicry of other objects it is at the expense of its own reality, and it falls from the species Sculpture, and becomes a sub-species or mutation of some other real object. Man, animals, plants, all other objects and phenomena in the world have a purpose other than just their visual appearance. The purpose of sculpture, as a self-contained object rather than a historical projection, is entirely and exclusively held in the way it is 'read'by the eye. As the eye physically 'sees' a two dimensional image, and the brain perceives by translating the information given in that image, the sculpture, as a new object in the world, must make its own particular three-dimensionality known to the eye, and its endeavour to do this is what makes all sculpture look the way it does. (Here again I must remind those who are infuriated by the reference to an autonomously-existing sculpture that I am looking only at the visually available remnants that we have left of other sculptors' expertise and skill, so that we can perhaps see how the common devices used to inform about the reality of the object have always been employed, The social and ideological context that makes sculpture possible or not, and allows or prevents continuity of tradition, is of no positive help to the sculptor. We are making sculpture, so sculpture is possible. The defects and attributes of our society and ideology may affect the content of our expression in a different way to any previous tradition, but I must ignore that here if a constant sculptural language is going to be seen as a plausible help to sculpture now.) The evolutionary movement of any sculptural tradition happens through the sculptor's continuing quest for a greater sculptural reality, or a better way of making the reality of the sculpture available to the eye. Sculptural _evolutions usually have primitive beginnings, (the embryonic utterance that is often very powerful in its simplicity and directness). They then Glynn Williams Rhino, 1978, constructed wood, 72"L x 49" H x 44"W move in a gentle upward curve as each generation of sculptors acquires a more articulate grasp of the sculptural language. The evolutionary curve reaches a high point of sculptural excellence when a full and subtle range of human expression can be handled. As a tradition evolves past this high point, often the sophistication and authority in handling the material, and the aesthetic skill available, tempt the sculptor, in his quest for greater sculptural reality, into mimicry of other real objects or phenomena. It is only at this very moment of manufacture that this mimicry of other outside objects will seem right. This external liaison with another reality will tie the sculpture to that object, and therefore to its time. It will never be free of that contemporary topical bond, nor will it be able to join with all other sculpture, moving through time ever available, relevant and alive. The result is the eventual collapse of the sculpture, the decline of the tradition, and the dip of the evolutionary curve. The objects will finally become dead versions or frozen moments of other realities. This view of the evolution of a scultptural tradition as a simple rising and descending curve is very generalised, and of course each different sculptural tradition has its own individual development characteristics. But basically it is useful, 5

Before looking across the contemporary landscape, peppered as it is with this great variety of forms, I am, for a moment, going to look exclusively at sculptures from previous traditions (which I am referring to as traditional sculpture). For the purpose of making my point more clearly, I am particularly referring to those traditions where sculpture developed as a somewhat self-conscious activity, where objective aesthetic decisions played a great part in moving the sculptural evolution onward. Rather than those more primitive traditions where one has to search in an anthropological area, outside of the sculpture, to find the reason for some of the symbols and forms. Every tradition has its own particularness that makes such generalisations risky, and some traditions such as, say, Egyptian sculpture, are both useful, in the sophisticated aesthetic behind t he sculpture, and also unhelpful as the religious and mystic restrictions prevented any easily observed evolutionary movement. However, I am looking at the objects we have in front of our eyes now; the society they grew in no longer exists with them. Such regard for the selfcontainedness of the objects and their realness, could by myopic, were it not for the fact that there is a set of constant recurring 'devices' in all sculpture that

53 Heol Siarl, Caerdydd CF1 4ED tel. 395548 53 Charles Street, Cardiff CF1 4ED tel. 395548

Harry Snook reliefs

September 6-29

A Scottish Arts Council / Welsh Arts Council touring exhibition in conjunctton with The Association of Illustrators

Open Monday-Friday 9.30-6.00; Saturday 9.30-5.30

move across traditions and are developed each time by the makers of the sculpture for the same visual reasons. T.S. Elliot proposed that the whole of art ever made forms a constant living 'lump'.The works already forming this 'lump',alter, depending on relevance, to accomodate new arrivals. Thus Greek sculpture changes somewhat as each later sculpture that refers to it is made. There are only old or dead societies; the art they produced is alive and constant, as long as we can understand it and use it. Certainly the British Museum isn't a history lesson for sculptors, all the objects in it are outside of any context or time, and have a selfcontained life given to them by their relevant usefulness in a continual understanding of sculpture.

A free-standing traditional sculpture belongs to a quite different art form to that of a painting or a relief sculpture. It is an expressive man-made object in the real world that is exclusively available through its visual appearance. Its presence in the world is real and can be appreciated by bumping into it, but that is not its true reality, or the reality it exists for. It has a three-dimensional reality as a credible object, which is entirely held in its visual sculptural language. Its own visual description of itself as an object, through its forms and devices, gives it this true reality, and puts it firmly into the species, or family of objects, called Sculpture. It is not a replication of any other item or phenomenon from the real world. Although it may approach and allude to other objects, it always remains essentially different from them. If it trespasses too near in its mimicry of other objects it is at the expense of its own reality, and it falls from the species Sculpture, and becomes a sub-species or mutation of some other real object.

Man, animals, plants, all other objects and phenomena in the world have a purpose other than just their visual appearance. The purpose of sculpture, as a self-contained object rather than a historical projection, is entirely and exclusively held in the way it is 'read'by the eye. As the eye physically 'sees' a two dimensional image, and the brain perceives by translating the information given in that image, the sculpture, as a new object in the world, must make its own particular three-dimensionality known to the eye, and its endeavour to do this is what makes all sculpture look the way it does. (Here again I must remind those who are infuriated by the reference to an autonomously-existing sculpture that I am looking only at the visually available remnants that we have left of other sculptors' expertise and skill, so that we can perhaps see how the common devices used to inform about the reality of the object have always been employed,

The social and ideological context that makes sculpture possible or not, and allows or prevents continuity of tradition, is of no positive help to the sculptor. We are making sculpture, so sculpture is possible. The defects and attributes of our society and ideology may affect the content of our expression in a different way to any previous tradition, but I must ignore that here if a constant sculptural language is going to be seen as a plausible help to sculpture now.)

The evolutionary movement of any sculptural tradition happens through the sculptor's continuing quest for a greater sculptural reality, or a better way of making the reality of the sculpture available to the eye. Sculptural _evolutions usually have primitive beginnings, (the embryonic utterance that is often very powerful in its simplicity and directness). They then

Glynn Williams Rhino, 1978, constructed wood, 72"L x 49" H x 44"W

move in a gentle upward curve as each generation of sculptors acquires a more articulate grasp of the sculptural language. The evolutionary curve reaches a high point of sculptural excellence when a full and subtle range of human expression can be handled. As a tradition evolves past this high point, often the sophistication and authority in handling the material, and the aesthetic skill available, tempt the sculptor, in his quest for greater sculptural reality, into mimicry of other real objects or phenomena. It is only at this very moment of manufacture that this mimicry of other outside objects will seem right. This external liaison with another reality will tie the sculpture to that object, and therefore to its time. It will never be free of that contemporary topical bond, nor will it be able to join with all other sculpture, moving through time ever available, relevant and alive. The result is the eventual collapse of the sculpture, the decline of the tradition, and the dip of the evolutionary curve. The objects will finally become dead versions or frozen moments of other realities.

This view of the evolution of a scultptural tradition as a simple rising and descending curve is very generalised, and of course each different sculptural tradition has its own individual development characteristics. But basically it is useful,

5

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content