Skip to main content
Read page text
page 9
But there are many 'realist' artists in Britain today who have no time for the extreme narcissism so characteristic of post-modernism. All of them are interested in actual life in the here and now , and have managed, so far, to fend off the blandishments of the dream, the disoriented bizarre episode, the disjoined or the schizophrenically confused. They are masters and mistresses of satirical drawing or painting- and sculpting- who would be happy to be associated with the tradition of critical realism stemming from Hogarth and Gillray, yet are nourished by the best of earlier twentieth century modernism.* This new form of realism will involve a renunciation of the exotic, the estranged and the bizarre and, because of its roots in actual experience, will prevail long after post-modernism has gone away. And it ' might make us look again at how art might function in a divided and threatened world. Notes 1. R . Barthes , Image-Music-Text, London 1977. 2. M. Foucault , 'What is an Author?' in V. Harari (ed) , Textual Strategies , London 1980. 3. A . Stephanson , interview with Fredric Jameson, Flash Art, 131 , Dec 86/Jan 87, p.69 . 4. New Left Review , no 146, July/August 1984. 5. F. Jameson , 'In the Destructive Element Immerse: Hans-Jurgen Syberberg and Cultural Revolution', October , 17 , 1981 , pp.l13-4 . 6. L. Tickner , quoting V. Burgin, 'Sexuality and in Representation: Five British Artists', in Difference, New York 1984. p .20. 7. J .F . Lyotard, The Post Modern Condition : a Report on Knowledge, Manchester 1984 , p.76 . 8. G. Lukacs , Realism in Our Time, 1956 ; English edition , 1981, p.30. 9. J . Berger , Looking Forward exhibition catalogue , London 1952. 10. J. Berger, New Statesman, 6 June 1959. 11. G. Marzorati, 'Kenny Scharfs Fun-House Big Bang', Art News , Sep 1985 , p.778. 12. J . Whitebrook , 'Reason an9 Happiness : Some Psychoanalytic Themes in Critical Theory', in R.J . Bernstein (ed) , Habermas and Modernity , 1985, p.l50. *In a new exhibition being planned by Juliet Steyn , Michael Wooton , Christopher Tunwell and myself for 1987-8, we choose the title 'Critical Realism' for a range of work which not merely shows the typical events and personalities of our time but which also combines a critical attitude with signs of man's capacity to overcome his conditions through humour and struggle. Many of the paintings of Denzil Forrester , Graham Crowley, John Keane, Sue Coe , Sonya Boyce, Ken Currie , Bob Robinson and John Yeadon fall into this category; together with the prints of Anthony Davies , the caricatures of Fluck and Law , or the satirical cartoons of Gerald Scarfe and Steve Bell . The colour photographs of Paul Graham and Paul Reas are admirable in their efforts to confront everyday reality in working-class life with the skills of the best documentary photographer . Likewise the veteran war reporter Don McCullin . These examples could be multiplied, up to a point. They show the seeds of a strong realist tradition in British art to be still very much alive , despite widespread assumptions to the contrary. The Art of Being British Anthony Barnett The Royal Academy show of modern British art poses some very interesting questions . But in a manner that sows confusion. I t seems like another case of 'the missing centre ' , in which praise and criticism alike go off at tangents or get tangled in cross-purposes. Take the exhibition's title and its now almost notorious sub-title. British Art in the 20th Century is clear and bold . I t promises to bring together the major works of our time - of the present and recent past - which will show us British Art , for good and ill. All national traditions are ambiguous and controversial , but if there is a point to a national show it is to 'bring in the wagons' and see how they add up. Then comes the sub-title : 'The Modern Movement'. I t is in no way pedantic to question this notion , in addition to its application to Britain. Is there something anywhere that can be termed 'The Modern Movement' in the singular- is there a Modern Movement? We can refer to 'modern art', because the impact and influence of the industrial revolutions have transformed planetary life, including its human art. Of course , some work is modern only in terms of the calendar and belongs in spirit to the past . I t does not follow that everything else is affiliated to one over-arching 'movement' that we can describe as 'themodern ' in art. Such a thing does not exist because the modern has been contested by the modern. Indeed one of the attributes of modernity is precisely the contradictory and heterogeneous character of its ouput and the hostile and opposing directions that have been asserted or explored in the name of modern art. All the same , we can step back and recognize that there has been some kind of modern 'impulse' in fine art , especially in the rest of Europe and in America. Looked at from these islands we can see that 'modern art ' - however contested was made 'over there' rather than here . However the British too made a contribution worthy of an exhibition . . . The point is obvious: that , even if there ever was a 'modern movement', the least likely place to find it is in the United Kingdom . If the Royal Academy had called their exhibition: The British Modern Movement, everyone would have said 'The what?' One response - a very British one would be to say who cares, what matters are the paintings . I almost agree with this. The paintings matter much more than any title or catalogue . But the question 'Is there such a thing as British art, and if so what is it?' - the question posed yet abandoned by the exhibition- is interesting and important , whether for painters and sculptors or for the many thousands who look at art in Britain. Another response might be to interpret the Academy show as an operation aimed at defining 'British art' in a peculiar way . The selection attempts to present varieties of British 'neo-expressionism'in a fashion that links what happened here to the development of art in central Europe, especially Germany. Such a selection might be dubious , but at least it is an overall argument. The trouble with it, if such it is, is that it locates the centre of modern British art outside Britain , without articulating this relationship clearly and without showing how it related to the rest of British art . At least such an interpretation helps to explain the exhibition 's 'foreign' character , that has so troubled critics. 'The show is especially partial to foreigners', notes Waldemar Janusczak, and (ominous phrase) 'those British artists who were of close-knit Jewish extraction'.1 For Michael Shepherd of the Sunday Telegraph, 'To most British visitors it will seem more international lager than British real ale . '2 But there is another possible explanation for the 'un-British' nature of this exhibition. One which also questions a primary assumption found frequently on the Left and Right about 'Art and the British'. Shepherd reproduces the received notions. The British are 'traditionally indifferent' to the arts , he claims . Hence numerous individuals could work away at their patches of canvas, happy to be left alone . The result is, a tilth for flowers , weeds and ramblers alike , which supports a huge variety of happy individual experiment and adventure and enjoyment , often mediocre by international standards, but which also allows outstanding talent, especially that of well motivated foreign settlers (sic), to work away quietly undisturbed and raise the standards of that mediocrity . This is a classic of English ideology. We are not much good at this art stuff, but we are sensible enough to allow in a few wogs to add a bit of colour to our lives. Of course, it won 't make much difference really . What Shepherd finds benign , Andrew Brighton excori ates. In last month 's Art Monthly he insisted in a memorable polemic : The bes t British a rt is rare ly made or bought by the English. By English I mean a mental- 9

But there are many 'realist' artists in Britain today who have no time for the extreme narcissism so characteristic of post-modernism. All of them are interested in actual life in the here and now , and have managed, so far, to fend off the blandishments of the dream, the disoriented bizarre episode, the disjoined or the schizophrenically confused. They are masters and mistresses of satirical drawing or painting- and sculpting- who would be happy to be associated with the tradition of critical realism stemming from Hogarth and Gillray, yet are nourished by the best of earlier twentieth century modernism.*

This new form of realism will involve a renunciation of the exotic, the estranged and the bizarre and, because of its roots in actual experience, will prevail long after post-modernism has gone away. And it ' might make us look again at how art might function in a divided and threatened world.

Notes 1. R . Barthes , Image-Music-Text, London

1977. 2. M. Foucault , 'What is an Author?' in V.

Harari (ed) , Textual Strategies , London 1980. 3. A . Stephanson , interview with Fredric

Jameson, Flash Art, 131 , Dec 86/Jan 87, p.69 . 4. New Left Review , no 146, July/August

1984. 5. F. Jameson , 'In the Destructive Element

Immerse: Hans-Jurgen Syberberg and Cultural Revolution', October , 17 , 1981 , pp.l13-4 . 6. L. Tickner , quoting V. Burgin, 'Sexuality and in Representation: Five British

Artists', in Difference, New York 1984. p .20. 7. J .F . Lyotard, The Post Modern Condition :

a Report on Knowledge, Manchester 1984 , p.76 . 8. G. Lukacs , Realism in Our Time, 1956 ;

English edition , 1981, p.30. 9. J . Berger , Looking Forward exhibition catalogue , London 1952. 10. J. Berger, New Statesman, 6 June 1959. 11. G. Marzorati, 'Kenny Scharfs Fun-House

Big Bang', Art News , Sep 1985 , p.778. 12. J . Whitebrook , 'Reason an9 Happiness :

Some Psychoanalytic Themes in Critical Theory', in R.J . Bernstein (ed) , Habermas and Modernity , 1985, p.l50.

*In a new exhibition being planned by Juliet Steyn , Michael Wooton , Christopher Tunwell and myself for 1987-8, we choose the title 'Critical Realism' for a range of work which not merely shows the typical events and personalities of our time but which also combines a critical attitude with signs of man's capacity to overcome his conditions through humour and struggle. Many of the paintings of Denzil Forrester , Graham Crowley, John Keane, Sue Coe , Sonya Boyce, Ken Currie , Bob Robinson and John Yeadon fall into this category; together with the prints of Anthony Davies , the caricatures of Fluck and Law , or the satirical cartoons of Gerald Scarfe and Steve Bell . The colour photographs of Paul Graham and Paul Reas are admirable in their efforts to confront everyday reality in working-class life with the skills of the best documentary photographer . Likewise the veteran war reporter Don McCullin . These examples could be multiplied, up to a point. They show the seeds of a strong realist tradition in British art to be still very much alive , despite widespread assumptions to the contrary.

The Art of Being British Anthony Barnett

The Royal Academy show of modern British art poses some very interesting questions . But in a manner that sows confusion. I t seems like another case of 'the missing centre ' , in which praise and criticism alike go off at tangents or get tangled in cross-purposes.

Take the exhibition's title and its now almost notorious sub-title. British Art in the 20th Century is clear and bold . I t promises to bring together the major works of our time - of the present and recent past - which will show us British Art , for good and ill. All national traditions are ambiguous and controversial , but if there is a point to a national show it is to 'bring in the wagons' and see how they add up.

Then comes the sub-title : 'The Modern Movement'. I t is in no way pedantic to question this notion , in addition to its application to Britain. Is there something anywhere that can be termed 'The Modern Movement' in the singular- is there a Modern Movement?

We can refer to 'modern art', because the impact and influence of the industrial revolutions have transformed planetary life, including its human art. Of course , some work is modern only in terms of the calendar and belongs in spirit to the past . I t does not follow that everything else is affiliated to one over-arching 'movement' that we can describe as 'themodern ' in art. Such a thing does not exist because the modern has been contested by the modern. Indeed one of the attributes of modernity is precisely the contradictory and heterogeneous character of its ouput and the hostile and opposing directions that have been asserted or explored in the name of modern art.

All the same , we can step back and recognize that there has been some kind of modern 'impulse' in fine art , especially in the rest of Europe and in America. Looked at from these islands we can see that 'modern art ' - however contested was made 'over there' rather than here . However the British too made a contribution worthy of an exhibition . . . The point is obvious: that , even if there ever was a

'modern movement', the least likely place to find it is in the United Kingdom . If the Royal Academy had called their exhibition: The British Modern Movement, everyone would have said 'The what?'

One response - a very British one would be to say who cares, what matters are the paintings . I almost agree with this. The paintings matter much more than any title or catalogue . But the question 'Is there such a thing as British art, and if so what is it?' - the question posed yet abandoned by the exhibition- is interesting and important , whether for painters and sculptors or for the many thousands who look at art in Britain.

Another response might be to interpret the Academy show as an operation aimed at defining 'British art' in a peculiar way . The selection attempts to present varieties of British 'neo-expressionism'in a fashion that links what happened here to the development of art in central Europe, especially Germany. Such a selection might be dubious , but at least it is an overall argument. The trouble with it, if such it is, is that it locates the centre of modern British art outside Britain , without articulating this relationship clearly and without showing how it related to the rest of British art .

At least such an interpretation helps to explain the exhibition 's 'foreign' character , that has so troubled critics. 'The show is especially partial to foreigners', notes Waldemar Janusczak, and (ominous phrase) 'those British artists who were of close-knit Jewish extraction'.1 For Michael Shepherd of the Sunday Telegraph, 'To most British visitors it will seem more international lager than British real ale . '2

But there is another possible explanation for the 'un-British' nature of this exhibition. One which also questions a primary assumption found frequently on the Left and Right about 'Art and the British'.

Shepherd reproduces the received notions. The British are 'traditionally indifferent' to the arts , he claims . Hence numerous individuals could work away at their patches of canvas, happy to be left alone . The result is,

a tilth for flowers , weeds and ramblers alike , which supports a huge variety of happy individual experiment and adventure and enjoyment , often mediocre by international standards, but which also allows outstanding talent, especially that of well motivated foreign settlers (sic), to work away quietly undisturbed and raise the standards of that mediocrity . This is a classic of English ideology. We are not much good at this art stuff, but we are sensible enough to allow in a few wogs to add a bit of colour to our lives. Of course, it won 't make much difference really .

What Shepherd finds benign , Andrew Brighton excori ates. In last month 's Art Monthly he insisted in a memorable polemic :

The bes t British a rt is rare ly made or bought by the English. By English I mean a mental-

9

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content