Skip to main content
Read page text
page 2
PAGE TWO THE EXPLODED MUSEUM Sarah Wilson Norman Foster, Carre d'Art, Nimes The Roman temple in the heart of the city of Nimes once faced the pillars of the Opera House, destroyed by fire in 1952, and much beloved by the old protestant high society of Nimes. The salvaged pillars of this edifice now mark the exit to the Aries motorway. Like a white phoenix, Norman Foster's Carre d'Art has risen in its place, though risen perhaps too slowly: it is 'mode 80' according to Le Monde, and 'a small Foster for a small town'. I t offers a gleaming and fragile glass counterpoint to the temple, La Maison Carre, whose proportions it attempts to echo with mathematical grace. Elements recognisable from the Royal Academy Sackler Galleries have been expanded to create a building that is both another city monument, witness to civic pride, and a functioning major art gallery, library and space for the people. 2 ART MONTHLY There are problems, for example the problem of competition between the building and internally erected walls, problems with the facilities for the display of works on paper, problems with light through pleasing blinds zebra-striping the walls. But the Parsian beau-monde descended for the opening to pronounce the building tres beau and to drink champagne in the adjacent Place d'Assas, graced with one of the two fountains with sculpture erected in the city by Martial Raysse. (Raysse's Jeu de Paume retrospective will travel to the Carre d'Art shortly, a Sigmar Polke show will follow in Summer 1994.) The inaugural exhibition, L'Ivresse du Reel, l'Objet dans le XXeme Siecle, is a conspectus of modernism: a room of Cubism, a room of Duchamp remakes, De Chirico, unusual Man Ray, Pop and Nouveau Realism, an
page 3
exceptionally large, tiled installation by Patrice Raynaud (of flowerpot fame) and a top floor with not only Warhol and Rauschenberg but also Jeff Koons' Hoover pieces and the ghastlier manifestations of international 'neo-baroque' dutifully purchased by the FRAC (Fonds Regional d'Art Contemporain). An exhibition devoted to the Solei/ Noir (Black Sun) press with wonderful beaux-livres collaborations between artists and writers signalled the aspirations of the library below. The exhibition halls surround an expanded, opaque glass staircase which cascades like a waterfall into the entrance and turns back on itself to a bar-terrasse which offers a magnificent view of the Roman Maison Carre and Nimes roofscape below. Beginning inside Foster's building, with a rare Elsworth Kelly monumental sculpture, Caul, (Richard Long's adjacent wall sculpture was not mentioned in the handout), sculpture extended to sites all over the town emphasising the concept of the Carre d'Art as a 'musee eclate' or 'exploded museum'. In the Town Hall courtyard, a Takis Signal with screw-like mast, a column by Bernard Pages from Nice in honour of Albert Camus (1985), and perhaps most successful, a jadegreen marble cube with a 'crocodile' of t iny cubes weaving through it by Philippe Starck - perhaps the most upmarket bus shelter in Europe (no sign of a bus stop). The ennobling aspirations extend to the fabulous decoration of the Quick hamburger palace by Claude Viallat, the Nimois artist of the Supports-Surfaces group, whose spirogyra-like shapes bedeck the nineteenth-century plaster-decorated ceilings, wall and pillars of a magnificent, double-height space. The most surprisingly successful, indeed moving, of all the projects was Julian Schnabel's triptych within the Roman Maison Carre itself. The old archeological museum was swept away and new blood-red walls created a backdrop for the three mostly abstract canvases . Painted in three weeks in 1990, Abelardo Martinez takes as its subject 'el espontaneo', the youngster who dives into the bull-ring to flaunt his prowess before the official toreador, who may either turn his back in rejection, or throw a proud glance of acknowledgement. (With regular bull-fights in its vast Roman arena, alternating with concerts by Johnny Halliday and Sting this season, Nimes is the second most important tourist town in France.) The refurbished Musee des Beaux-Arts, with its central Roman mosaic pavement, participates in the 'exploded museum' concept, and displays a tactful choice of works such as Jean-Michel Alberola's multiple painting, Presentation du Toreador Aleatoire, 1985, which with its sequential pirouette of bullfight steps further accentuates Nimes' Latin/Mediterranean her- Norman Foater, Carre d'Art, Nimea itage. This is complemented by a choice of contemporary art from Germany and America, including a light installation on the rotunda by Jarnes Turrell. There is also a judicious selection of young British artists, among them, Simon Linke and Rachel Whiteread. The Jesuit chapel in the centre of town continues the tradition, so successfully promoted by the French, of showing art in places impregnated with time and a sense of the sacred. The selection comes from the FRAC Languedoc-Roussillon. Christian Boltanski's memorial piece in a side-chapel, grey tins filling the space almost to the ceiling- a rusting columbariumacquired maximum poignancy and resonance here. The Nimois to whom I spoke had plenty to say about the Carre d'Art. Proud that it appeared in the national press, they were dubious about it and the entire 'exploded museum' in terms of money and viability. (The town contributed FFr 278m to a total cost of FFr 383m for the nine-year Carre d'Art building project alone.) Nimes is not a university town; it lacks the youth and the intellectual life of Aix or even Nice, once the tourists have left for the year. The mayor of Nimes, Jean Bousquet, essentially a man of the right, appeared as town saviour after the huge flood of 1988. He has been responsible for a project which has not been without elements of selfaggrandisement, a literal'intoxication of the real'. The scale, taste and perfection of the exercise, however, can only make the British blush (a detailed political and economic comparison with Birmingham would be interesting). While one is happy to salute a considerable achievement by Norman Foster, the lasting impression is one of the fragility of this 'high art' enterprise. An exhibition by Jessica Stockholder organised by the Carre d'Art is at the Galerie des Arenes, Nimes to Sept 26 1993. Sarah Wilson lectures at the Courtauld Institute of Art, London. ART MONTHLY 3

exceptionally large, tiled installation by Patrice Raynaud (of flowerpot fame) and a top floor with not only Warhol and Rauschenberg but also Jeff Koons' Hoover pieces and the ghastlier manifestations of international 'neo-baroque' dutifully purchased by the FRAC (Fonds Regional d'Art Contemporain). An exhibition devoted to the Solei/ Noir (Black Sun) press with wonderful beaux-livres collaborations between artists and writers signalled the aspirations of the library below.

The exhibition halls surround an expanded, opaque glass staircase which cascades like a waterfall into the entrance and turns back on itself to a bar-terrasse which offers a magnificent view of the Roman Maison Carre and Nimes roofscape below. Beginning inside Foster's building, with a rare Elsworth Kelly monumental sculpture, Caul, (Richard Long's adjacent wall sculpture was not mentioned in the handout), sculpture extended to sites all over the town emphasising the concept of the Carre d'Art as a 'musee eclate' or 'exploded museum'. In the Town Hall courtyard, a Takis Signal with screw-like mast, a column by Bernard Pages from Nice in honour of Albert Camus (1985), and perhaps most successful, a jadegreen marble cube with a 'crocodile' of t iny cubes weaving through it by Philippe Starck - perhaps the most upmarket bus shelter in Europe (no sign of a bus stop).

The ennobling aspirations extend to the fabulous decoration of the Quick hamburger palace by Claude Viallat, the Nimois artist of the Supports-Surfaces group, whose spirogyra-like shapes bedeck the nineteenth-century plaster-decorated ceilings, wall and pillars of a magnificent, double-height space. The most surprisingly successful, indeed moving, of all the projects was Julian Schnabel's triptych within the Roman Maison Carre itself. The old archeological museum was swept away and new blood-red walls created a backdrop for the three mostly abstract canvases . Painted in three weeks in 1990, Abelardo Martinez takes as its subject 'el espontaneo', the youngster who dives into the bull-ring to flaunt his prowess before the official toreador, who may either turn his back in rejection, or throw a proud glance of acknowledgement. (With regular bull-fights in its vast Roman arena, alternating with concerts by Johnny Halliday and Sting this season, Nimes is the second most important tourist town in France.)

The refurbished Musee des Beaux-Arts, with its central Roman mosaic pavement, participates in the 'exploded museum' concept, and displays a tactful choice of works such as Jean-Michel Alberola's multiple painting, Presentation du Toreador Aleatoire, 1985, which with its sequential pirouette of bullfight steps further accentuates Nimes' Latin/Mediterranean her-

Norman Foater, Carre d'Art, Nimea itage. This is complemented by a choice of contemporary art from Germany and America, including a light installation on the rotunda by Jarnes Turrell. There is also a judicious selection of young British artists, among them, Simon Linke and Rachel Whiteread.

The Jesuit chapel in the centre of town continues the tradition, so successfully promoted by the French, of showing art in places impregnated with time and a sense of the sacred. The selection comes from the FRAC Languedoc-Roussillon. Christian Boltanski's memorial piece in a side-chapel, grey tins filling the space almost to the ceiling- a rusting columbariumacquired maximum poignancy and resonance here.

The Nimois to whom I spoke had plenty to say about the Carre d'Art. Proud that it appeared in the national press, they were dubious about it and the entire 'exploded museum' in terms of money and viability. (The town contributed FFr 278m to a total cost of FFr 383m for the nine-year Carre d'Art building project alone.) Nimes is not a university town; it lacks the youth and the intellectual life of Aix or even Nice, once the tourists have left for the year.

The mayor of Nimes, Jean Bousquet, essentially a man of the right, appeared as town saviour after the huge flood of 1988. He has been responsible for a project which has not been without elements of selfaggrandisement, a literal'intoxication of the real'. The scale, taste and perfection of the exercise, however, can only make the British blush (a detailed political and economic comparison with Birmingham would be interesting). While one is happy to salute a considerable achievement by Norman Foster, the lasting impression is one of the fragility of this 'high art' enterprise.

An exhibition by Jessica Stockholder organised by the Carre d'Art is at the Galerie des Arenes, Nimes to Sept 26 1993.

Sarah Wilson lectures at the Courtauld Institute of Art, London.

ART MONTHLY 3

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content