Skip to main content
Read page text
page 6
Contents Introduction by Clive Wilmer Editorial Note vii xvi I The Poet in the Imaginary Museum (1957) II T.S. Eliot: The End of an Era (1956) II The Young Yeats (1960) IV The Relation between Syntax and Music in Some Modern Poems in English (1961) V Two Analogies for Poetry (1962) VI Ezra Pound’s Hugh Selwyn Mauberley (1961) VII The ‘Sculpture’ of Rhyme (1961) VIII Michael Ayrton’s The Maze Maker (1969) IX Mr Eliot (1963) X Pound and Eliot: A Distinction (1970) XI T.S. Eliot – 1928 (1966) XII Yeats, The Master of a Trade (1964) XIII Michael Robartes and the Dancer (1965) XIV Cypress versus Rock-Slide: An Appreciation of Canto 110 (1970) 1 13 25 34 47 53 66 67 79 84 103 105 113 127 XV The Adventures of a Cultural Orphan (1971) 134 XVI The Universe of Ezra Pound (1972) 138 XVII Eliot in One Poet’s Life (1972) 145 XVIII Anglican Eliot (1973) XIX The Modernist malgré lui (1984) 159 169 XX A Fascist Poem: Yeats’s ‘Blood and the Moon’ (1979) 176 XXI Poets on Stilts: Yeats and Some Contemporaries (1982) 182 XXII The Franglais of Criticism; the English of Translation (1983) 192 XXIII The Mysterious Allen Upward (1990) 203 XXIV ‘The Dry Salvages’: A Reconsideration (1991) 216 XXV A Son of Ezra (1995) 228 XXVI Ezra Pound in Pisa (1968) 242 Index 243
page 7
Introduction In his first critical book, Purity of Diction in English Verse (1952), Donald Davie wrote: ‘there is no denying that modern poetry is obscure and that it would be less so if the poets adhered to the syntax of prose’. Taken out of context, this may surprise those of his readers who think of him as an authority on Modernism, especially as a champion of Ezra Pound. Of course, in the sentence I have quoted he is not exactly condemning the obscurity, but there is an implication that another sort of poetry would be preferable – for instance, the late Augustan verse he explores and celebrates in the book in question. Davie admires such poetry for its lucidity, its verbal restraint (‘pure diction’) and the attention its language pays to the world of fact. But he is also conscious that literary nostalgia and the kind of critical alertness he practises do not cohabit happily. In ‘Homage to William Cowper’, a poem of the same period, he calls himself ‘A pasticheur of late Augustan styles’, but he is all too aware that the committed pasticheur is merely a sentimentalist and that, if poetry is to thrive, it must engage with the reality of the world it is written for and must do so in the language of its time. That reality and that language are the products of historical developments, which for the poet have to include both the Romantic and the Modernist revolutions. In a chapter on Coleridge he records the moment when ‘pure diction’ is discarded in favour of divine afflatus, to which such purity is alien. The poem ceases to be an object in the world ‘out there’ and becomes instead a mode of expression. In consequence, the reader is no longer concerned with matters of objective fact but with the unique self of the inspired speaker: This is one of the most momentous changes in the history of poetry. It marks the disappearance of the Renaissance conviction about the poem as a made thing, thrown free of its makar, something added to creation and free-standing in its own right. The poet hereafter is legislator, seer, scapegoat and reporter; he is no longer an artificer. It is therefore no accident that this book on the late Augustans is also concerned with more recent poetry. In particular, it has much to say, most of it sceptical and mildly adverse, about the Modernist masters: about W.B.Yeats, T.S. Eliot and, above all, Ezra Pound. It is important to remember that, though Davie was an academic by profession, he always wrote as a poet. Interesting as literary history might be, the nub of

Contents

Introduction by Clive Wilmer

Editorial Note vii xvi

I The Poet in the Imaginary Museum (1957)

II T.S. Eliot: The End of an Era (1956)

II The Young Yeats (1960)

IV The Relation between Syntax and Music in

Some Modern Poems in English (1961)

V Two Analogies for Poetry (1962)

VI Ezra Pound’s Hugh Selwyn Mauberley (1961)

VII The ‘Sculpture’ of Rhyme (1961)

VIII Michael Ayrton’s The Maze Maker (1969)

IX Mr Eliot (1963)

X Pound and Eliot: A Distinction (1970)

XI T.S. Eliot – 1928 (1966)

XII Yeats, The Master of a Trade (1964)

XIII Michael Robartes and the Dancer (1965)

XIV Cypress versus Rock-Slide: An Appreciation of

Canto 110 (1970)

1

13

25

34

47

53

66

67

79

84

103

105

113

127

XV The Adventures of a Cultural Orphan (1971)

134

XVI The Universe of Ezra Pound (1972)

138

XVII Eliot in One Poet’s Life (1972)

145

XVIII Anglican Eliot (1973)

XIX The Modernist malgré lui (1984)

159

169

XX A Fascist Poem: Yeats’s ‘Blood and the Moon’ (1979) 176 XXI Poets on Stilts: Yeats and Some Contemporaries (1982) 182 XXII The Franglais of Criticism; the English of Translation (1983) 192 XXIII The Mysterious Allen Upward (1990) 203 XXIV ‘The Dry Salvages’: A Reconsideration (1991) 216 XXV A Son of Ezra (1995) 228 XXVI Ezra Pound in Pisa (1968) 242

Index

243

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content