Skip to main content
Read page text
page 15
| FEATURES 02 | MARIA WALSH POSITS THE END OF CRITIQUE Just as criticism and the exercise of value judgements based on consensus was questioned by critique, shouldn’t critique now make way for an embedded form of criticality which helps to produce meaning in art? Gerard Byrne Subject 2009 video OCT 16 | ART MONTHLY | 400 The current fatigue with critique in art has been brewing in the West for at least a quarter of a century. Twenty-three years ago, in an October roundtable, Rosalind Krauss bemoaned the perceived fact that no one looks at ‘the work’ in the work of art any more. Art, as she saw it then in 1993, was instead being delimited by the critical apparatus and the institutional frame in which it appeared – her example was how Cindy Sherman’s work was co- opted for feminist theoretical agendas. Hal Foster’s response to her presages the growing obsolescence of the enlightenment project of critique. For him, the historical originality of contemporary art then was that its critical delimitation had become immanent to the work itself; in other words, works of art were including their own critique and context within themselves, thereby displacing the critic and critique as a separate sphere of judgement. This condition has been exacerbated in the recent rise in a culture of art as research, which seems more suited to exploring the global circulations, cultural dif erences and translations that circulate in our world and which is much too complex to be objectified in transcendent critique. These days, artworks incorporate archival, documentary and laboratory methods and forms which trace and evaluate their own construction and dissemination both within and outside themselves. One of the more memorable of the many times I have been hit with the impact of this modus operandi was at Olivia Plender’s 2009 exhibition at Gasworks ‘AADIEU ADIEU APA (Goodbye Goodbye Father)’, an installation comprising three components which commented on the UK’s imperial past and its legacy. The exhibition included: a repurposed model of the pavilions in the 1924 British Empire exhibition in Wembley; a video work What is England? in which a pseudo-TV presenter commented on British customs as well as the regeneration at Wembley today; and a series of posters based on examples of popular printing through the ages that satirised ‘seemingly incongruous historical occurrences relating to the themes of nationalism, trade and consumption’. Critique was so immanent within the frame and forms of this installation that there was no need to adjudicate, but simply to reflect on one’s own implication in this politically distributed and expanded field. | 13 |

| FEATURES 02 |

MARIA WALSH POSITS THE END OF CRITIQUE

Just as criticism and the exercise of value judgements based on consensus was questioned by critique, shouldn’t critique now make way for an embedded form of criticality which helps to produce meaning in art?

Gerard Byrne Subject 2009 video

OCT 16 | ART MONTHLY | 400

The current fatigue with critique in art has been brewing in the West for at least a quarter of a century. Twenty-three years ago, in an October roundtable, Rosalind Krauss bemoaned the perceived fact that no one looks at ‘the work’ in the work of art any more. Art, as she saw it then in 1993, was instead being delimited by the critical apparatus and the institutional frame in which it appeared – her example was how Cindy Sherman’s work was co- opted for feminist theoretical agendas. Hal Foster’s response to her presages the growing obsolescence of the enlightenment project of critique. For him, the historical originality of contemporary art then was that its critical delimitation had become immanent to the work itself; in other words, works of art were including their own critique and context within themselves, thereby displacing the critic and critique as a separate sphere of judgement. This condition has been exacerbated in the recent rise in a culture of art as research, which seems more suited to exploring the global circulations, cultural dif erences and translations that circulate in our world and which is much too complex to be objectified in transcendent critique.

These days, artworks incorporate archival, documentary and laboratory methods and forms which trace and evaluate their own construction and dissemination both within and outside themselves. One of the more memorable of the many times I have been hit with the impact of this modus operandi was at Olivia Plender’s 2009 exhibition at Gasworks ‘AADIEU ADIEU APA (Goodbye Goodbye Father)’, an installation comprising three components which commented on the UK’s imperial past and its legacy. The exhibition included: a repurposed model of the pavilions in the 1924 British Empire exhibition in Wembley; a video work What is England? in which a pseudo-TV presenter commented on British customs as well as the regeneration at Wembley today; and a series of posters based on examples of popular printing through the ages that satirised ‘seemingly incongruous historical occurrences relating to the themes of nationalism, trade and consumption’. Critique was so immanent within the frame and forms of this installation that there was no need to adjudicate, but simply to reflect on one’s own implication in this politically distributed and expanded field.

| 13 |

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content