r-NP£VI€W
Volume 16 Number 2
General Editors: MICHAEL SCHMIDT MICHAEL FREEMAN Contributing Editors:
DICK DAVIS JOHN PILLING NICOLAS TREDELL
STUART HOOD GABRIEL JOSIPOVICI ROBYN MARSACK
RUTH MORSE MARK THOMPSON Published six times a year.
Editorial office: 208-212 Corn Exchange Manchester M4 3BQ
All rights reserved.
Copyright © POETRY NATION REVIEW 1989 The editors acknowledge the financial assistanceof the Arts Council of Great
Britain Subscription (six issues): £16.50 (S28.50) individuals £21.00 (S36.00) institutions to PN REVIEW 208-212 Corn Exchange Manchester M4 3BQ
Manuscripts should be sent to the editonal otTicc jnd cannot be returned unless accompanied by a self-addressed and stamped envelope or by international reply coupons for writers living abroad. ISSN 0144-7076 The illustrations in this issue are from Thomas Bewick S e lected W orks edited by Robyn Marsack published by Carcanct Press
Printed in England by SRP Ltd. Exeter
3 Editorial 4 Letters 5 News & Notes
Reports 7 Leonardo Sciascia; An Honest Writer in a Difficult Land 8 J.M . Cohen 9 John Ashbery Two Poems 11 Christopher Middleton For Burning 16 F .T . Prince Crabbed Age and Youth 17 Edgar Bowers Three Poems 19 Adolf Muschg .. And Gifted with Hearing’ 24 E J . Scovell Tree in Light Wind 25 Thom Gunn at Sixty
26 Introduction 27 Thom Gunn Four Poems 29 Donald Hall Thom Gunn 31 Douglas Chambers Thom Gunn 32 Dick Davis Thom Gunn 33 Martin Dodsworth Gunn’s Rhymes 35 John Peck On Two Stanzas by Thom Gunn 37 Michael Schmidt Gunn, for example 38 Donald Davie Thom Gunn 39 Neil Powell Loud Music, Bars and Boisterous Men 42 Robert Pinsky Thom Gunn 44 Ted Hughes Lines about Elias 44 T im o th y Steele For Thom Gunn, Thinking o f him in Vermont 45 August Kleinzahler Two Poems for Thom Gunn 45 Clive Wilmer Letter to Thom Gunn 46 Janet Lewis Trophy W.W.l 46 Michael Vince For Thom Gunn’s Birthday 47 Helen Pinkerton On Caravaggio’s ‘Conversion o f St Paul’ 47 Dick Davis Two Medieval Persian Poems 47 R .L . Barth Elixir 47 Colin Falck An Art that Nature Makes 48 Charles GuIIans Directions 48 Vikram Seth Thom Gunn 48 Jim Powell Two Poems for Thom Gunn 49 Raymond Oliver My Sad Captains 49 Donald Davie Chernobyl. A Disaster 52 Jim Powell An Interview with Thom Gunn Reviews
Poetry 57 Donald Davie on A Various Art 59 T .j.G . Harris on Kathleen Rainc, Thomas Blackburn et al 62 Andrew Waterman on Hugo Williams and David Harsent 64 Neil Powell on Phoebe Hesketh