THE TABLET Founded in 1840 Vol. 225 No. 6843 31 July 1971 10p
Long Knives in the Sudan; Voting in the Great Debate; A Curial Constitu tion ................. 733
YUGOSLAVIA AT THE CROSS ROADS
K. F. Cviic ............................... 736
TWO VIEWS OF MR. WILSON :
1. Lord Longford
2. Douglas Woodruff
HANS RUNG : AN ANGLICAN APPRAISAL
E. L. Mascall
OUR NOTEBOOK ................. 741
T. S. Gregory; Alec Randall; Vincent Cronin; A. Gregory Murray; Illtud Evans, O.P.; Tudor Edwards ................. 742
IN THE MARGIN
THE ARTS :
Mary Crozier; Maryvonne Butcher; John Chambers; Adrian Brookholding - Jones 746
LETTERS ............................... 747
THE LIVING SPIRIT
CHURCH IN THE W ORLD :
Aid Agencies Fear Take-Over Bid; Hans Kiing Arraigned; Proposed Church Constitution: Cardinal Daniélou Attempts Counter-Weight to Cardinal Suenens’s Interview; the Church and the Cuban Revolution— a Clash of Views 751
LIBERATION OF MAN : TASK FOR THE SEVENTIES
Philip Daniel .
Dom Columban Mulcahy; Adrian Green-Armytage . . . 755
LONG KNIVES IN THE SUDAN
A NUMBER of intriguing questions arise out of the unsuccessful Communist coup in the Sudan. They affect not only that country but Africa and the Middle East and— at one remove— the interests of the super-Powers.
The Sudan is not only the largest country in Africa, it is also the link between the Arab world and the world of black Africa. Two-thirds of its population are Arab Muslims, one third Christians or animists. Bordering on Egypt, Libya, Chad, the Central African Republic, the Congo, Uganda, Kenya and Ethiopia and looking over the Red Sea to Saudi Arabia and the Yemen, the Sudan is clearly a country whose rulers can have lines open to key points over a vast area.
Background to the Hijacking The attempted coup coincided with the nineteenth anniversary of Colonel Nasser’s successful coup against King Farouk, and with the opening of the televised trial of the pro-Soviet Egyptian leaders, accused of having plotted against President Anwar Sadat. It did not take the Cairo Establishment completely by surprise. First it was believed that the Soviet military mission stationed in the Sudan approved of the conspiracy. Later, increasing and substantiated evidence came to hand that Communist China was also supporting the uprising against el Numeiry. In the context of Chairman Mao’s new foreign policy, this was as disturbing to the Russians as to President Sadat, not to mention General el Numeiry. The Sudanese Communist Party has, for some time, been split from top to bottom. No exact answer can be given as to which of the two Communist Powers had the largest share in preparing the coup. General el Numeiry, in his bloody purge, aims at eliminating both Maoist and Brezhnev-type Communists.
Who carried out the hijacking of the British aircraft, from which the Communist President-to-be, and the Prime Minister-to-be, were taken off by the Libyans, and sent to el Numeiry in Khartoum ? The most interesting element in the story is the part played by Flight Information Region. Malta. It is run by International Aeradio Ltd., in which BOAC is the largest shareholder. Only its three top officials are British, the rest are Maltese. When Cantain Bowyer received the order to land at Benghazi, he called Malta and requested clearance to return to Rome. The answer was yes. But a few minutes iater, simultaneously with the Libyan threat. “ For the safety of the souls on board you are to land in Benghazi ” , Malta advised him that Rome had rescinded its permission. One would require proof of this to believe it. In view of the friendly relations between Dom Mintoff and Colonel Mansur Ghaddafy, and the negotiations for a fifteen-million-pound grant “ without strings ” from Libya, Malta’s action is significant.
Can General el Numeiry join the Egypt-Libya-Syria confederation ? He was present at the original meeting of the three Heads of State (President Nasser was still alive) and signed the Tripoli Alliance. But when the plan was made final last April, he tactfully bowed out without appending his signature. His official reason was two-fold: that the confederation included Syria, a nonAfrican State, and that it was moving too rapidly towards political union.
In actual fact, el Numeiry cannot join the Tripoli Alliance, for this would block for ever a peaceful solution of the southern problem— a euphemism for the civil war which has been raging in the South for the last fifteen years (see The Tablet, 15 February 1971). The rebel Anyana leaders would never reach settlement with the north if the Sudan were part of an Arab bloc.
Colonel Ghaddafy of Libya regards himself as the new Mahdi, the Holy Man, who is to purify the Muslim faith and lead one hundred million Arabs to greatness. They must wage a Holy War against Israel and wipe it off the map. Ghadaffy resents el Numeiry’s caution, and his “ excessive concern ” over his African subjects; but he is in complete agreement with el Numeiry’s anticommunist attitude.
Russians Beset Finally, how will Moscow react to the failure of the first effort to establish a Communist régime on African soil ? It is known that the Moscow leaders were somewhat concerned over the unstable attitude of General el Numeiry— for instance when he suddenly, without any previous preparations, flew to Moscow. Yet el Numeiry succeeded in obtaining Soviet support without having to change his tactics towards the Sudanese Communists. Last September he dismissed from the Revolutionary Command Council Major Hasem al Atta, Colonel Babikr el Noor Osman and Major Farouk Hamadallah Osman, who staged the latest coup against him. Now, el Numeiry is wiping out the Sudanese Communist leadership, and is purging Communists from all walks of life. Whether he will succeed in changing the minds of the Omdurman railway workers, who are convinced Marxists, remains to be seen.
The Soviet leaders have had to learn —what the West is also apt to forget—