Skip to main content
Read page text
page 22
RECORDINGS OF THE YEAR Awards issue Not many Semiramide conductors have made successful traversals of Wagner’s Ring but Mark Elder has,   and it shows Richard Osborne welcomes an outstanding recording of Rossini’s Semiramide, with the classy cast and orchestra responding superbly to Mark Elder’s inspired direction Rossini Semiramide Albina Shagimuratova sop �Semiramide Daniela Barcellona mez �Arsace Mirco Palazzi bass �Assur Barry Banks ten �Idreno Susana Gaspar sop �Azema Gianluca Buratto bass �Oroe James Platt bass �Ghost of Nino David Butt Philip ten �Mitrane Opera Rara Chorus; Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment / Sir Mark Elder Opera Rara F d ORC57 (3h 54’ • DDD) Inlcudes synopsis, libretto and translation Semiramide is the last, and longest, of the 32 operas Rossini wrote for Italy. Based on Voltaire’s tragedy Sémiramis (1748), it tells of the Babylonian queen; the wiles of Assur, her former lover with whom she had conspired to kill her husband, the late king; and the Orestes-like return of her abandoned son Arsace. There are echoes, too, of Hamlet and Macbeth, plays admired by Voltaire in his youth. Rossini’s treatment is essentially neoclassical, more JacquesLouis David than Théodore Géricault, as this finely conceived and superbly executed new Opera Rara recording readily affirms. Beguiled though we were by the somewhat abbreviated 1966 Decca recording featuring Joan Sutherland and the young Marilyn Horne, it was not until the publication of Philip Gossett’s new Critical Edition in 1990 that we realised how grand an experience a complete Semiramide can be. New York’s Metropolitan Opera saluted the edition with a powerful new staging (ArtHaus Musik, A/02 – nla) featuring June Anderson, Marilyn Horne and Samuel Ramey, a famous Assur; but with the complete opera occupying a full five hours in the theatre, this too had to be to cut. Deutsche Grammophon made the first complete recording in 1992. Plausibly and powerfully cast, it ought to have worked but didn’t, due largely to Ion Marin’s reckless conducting. Twenty years later Naxos recorded it, live and complete, at the Rossini in Wildbad Festival; but this, too, proved unsatisfactory, upended by a vocally challenged Semiramide and some stand-andstare (as opposed to boy‑racer) conducting. All this talk of conductors might seem odd given that with Semiramide ears are invariably turned to the voices. So let it be said that the new Semiramide, the lavishly gifted Russian coloratura Albina Shagimuratova, she of the shining high E, and Daniela Barcellona, our finest contemporary Arsace, are both superb. ‘Serbami ognor’ is sublime but go PH O T O G R A P H Y D U N C A N : R U S S E L L 22 GRAMOPHONE RECORDINGS OF THE YEAR 2018 Click on a CD cover to buy/stream from gramophone.co.uk
page 23
Awards issue Editor’s Choices RECORDINGS OF THE YEAR BRAHMS Four Symphonies Berlin Staatskapelle / Daniel Barenboim DG Barenboim’s superb leadership of the Berlin Staatskapelle – primarily an opera orchestra – reaps more dividends here in powerful performances of Brahms’s orchestral masterpieces. KORNGOLD. NIELSEN Violin Concertos Jiyoon Lee vn Odense Symphony Orchestra / Kristiina Poska Orchid Our One to Watch in July more than justifies us drawing your attention to her: a Nielsen and Korngold pairing of real drama and virtuosity. STENHAMMAR Symphony No 2, etc Antwerp Symphony Orchestra / Christian Lindberg BIS The scope and moving themes of Swedish composer Stenhammar’s symphony are brilliantly conveyed here by Christian Lindberg and his Antwerp musicians. GÁL. SHOSTAKOVICH Piano Trios Briggs Piano Trio Avie This wonderful album is another beautifully played addition to the Hans Gál catalogue, early 20th-century chamber music which charms and engages throughout. PAGANINI Sonatas for Violin and Guitar Fabio Biondi vn Giangiacomo Pinardi gtr Glossa Both the instruments – violin and guitar – and interpreters feel delightfully paired here, in sound and in spirit. A lovely and lively listen. JS BACH Six Solo Cello Suites Yo-Yo Ma vc Sony Classical The acclaimed virtuoso’s third traversal on record through Bach’s profound Solo Cello Suites is one rich in character and sensitivity; personal and deeply reflective music-making. LOURIÉ Piano Works Christian Erny pf Ars Produktion This is a captivating programme of refined and evocatively coloured piano works by the 20th-century Russian composer, beautifully played by Christian Erny and captured in a gorgeoussounding acoustic. DEBUSSY ‘Harmonie du soir’ Sophie Karthäuser sop Stéphane Degout bar Alain Planès, Eugene Asti pf Harmonia Mundi As ‘Debussy year’ passes into its autumnal phase, here’s a delightful vocal addition to the celebrations; singing and playing throughout are wonderful. ‘DECADES – A CENTURY OF SONG’ Sols; Malcolm Martineau pf Vivat Vivat’s imaginative approach to exploring 19th-century song, a decade at a time, reaches the 1830s: nine composers, three languages, a number of rarities and some outstanding singing. to ‘Ebbene, a te, ferisci’, Semiramide’s echo of the closet scene in Hamlet and as difficult a duet as any in Italian opera, and you will realise just how good they really are. That said, not the least of the revolutions Rossini’s late operas unleashed on the world was the need for a fully functioning conductor. Not many Semiramide conductors have made successful traversals of Wagner’s Ring but Mark Elder has, and it shows. At points of crisis such as the apocalyptic first finale, this is an intensely theatrical performance, yet there is no rush in the larger shaping of the piece. The classic marriage of exact rhythms, a firm pulse and the speaking beauty of the vocal overlays makes for a continuously expressive unfolding of the musical narrative. Then there is the orchestra. Though Elder had blazed a trail by using the period-instrument Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment for his thrilling 1992 London concert performance of Rossini’s Ermione, elsewhere modern singers and old instruments continued to unhorse one another in post-1800 repertory. Not here. And what a difference the old instruments make. It will be difficult to hear Semiramide again without the melancholy beauty of the period horns and bassoons, the hieratic splendour of the brass, the distinctive timbres of the solo winds, clear as a May morning, or the rasp and sinister atmospheric charge of the lower strings. Elder’s presence is also a boon to the young Italian bass Mirco Palazzi, a late substitution in the role of Assur. If Palazzi finesses the odd moment of largely redundant coloratura, the role’s dramatic essences are strongly distilled, not least the pivotal Act 2 duet, where Assur and Semiramide row like the Macbeths, and Assur’s great mad scene, where Elder’s torrential conducting helps add cubits to the performance’s stature. It speaks volumes that in Assur’s delirious ‘Deh! ti ferma’, a Rigoletto-like lament, lofty yet freighted with despair, even Marin’s Samuel Ramey is outscored. The vocally resplendent Italian bass Gianluca Buratto is an imposing High Priest and Barry Banks gives a typically well-crafted reading of the stratospherically high role of the hapless Indian king Idreno, both his arias happily intact. At the end, it’s the old king’s ghost, not Oroe, who orders the killing of Assur, an imaginative take on a change Rossini might have made for Paris in 1825. There were other changes in Paris in an attempt to improve the opera’s problematic end. But only text survives, no music, alas. In the 1966 Bonynge recording, the state entrance of Idreno and his entourage in Act 1 is cut to shreds and the onstage banda parts (unknown at the time) are missing. Helped by first-rate choral work, how splendid that all now sounds, the whole thing magnificently preserved in the acoustically superb recording Steve Portnoi and producer Jeremy Hayes have conjured up for us. It’s a bespoke studio recording, of course; expensive to produce but, my goodness, what a difference that makes. gramophone.co.uk Click on a CD cover to buy/stream from GRAMOPHONE RECORDINGS OF THE YEAR 2018 23

Page Text

View plaintext

RECORDINGS OF THE YEAR

Awards issue

Not many Semiramide conductors have made successful traversals of Wagner’s Ring but Mark Elder has,   and it shows

Richard Osborne welcomes an outstanding recording of Rossini’s Semiramide, with the classy cast and orchestra responding superbly to Mark Elder’s inspired direction

Rossini Semiramide Albina Shagimuratova sop �Semiramide Daniela Barcellona mez �Arsace Mirco Palazzi bass �Assur Barry Banks ten �Idreno Susana Gaspar sop �Azema Gianluca Buratto bass �Oroe James Platt bass �Ghost of Nino David Butt Philip ten �Mitrane Opera Rara Chorus; Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment / Sir Mark Elder Opera Rara F d ORC57 (3h 54’ • DDD) Inlcudes synopsis, libretto and translation Semiramide is the last, and longest, of the 32 operas Rossini wrote for Italy. Based on Voltaire’s tragedy Sémiramis (1748), it tells of the Babylonian queen; the wiles of Assur, her former lover with whom she had conspired to kill her husband, the late king; and the Orestes-like return of her abandoned son Arsace. There are echoes, too, of Hamlet and Macbeth, plays admired by Voltaire in his youth. Rossini’s treatment is essentially neoclassical, more JacquesLouis David than Théodore Géricault, as this finely conceived and superbly executed new Opera Rara recording readily affirms.

Beguiled though we were by the somewhat abbreviated 1966 Decca recording featuring Joan Sutherland and the young Marilyn Horne, it was not until the publication of Philip Gossett’s new Critical Edition in 1990 that we realised how grand an experience a complete Semiramide can be. New York’s Metropolitan Opera saluted the edition with a powerful new staging (ArtHaus Musik, A/02 – nla) featuring June Anderson, Marilyn Horne and Samuel Ramey, a famous Assur; but with the complete opera occupying a full five hours in the theatre, this too had to be to cut.

Deutsche Grammophon made the first complete recording in 1992. Plausibly and powerfully cast, it ought to have worked but didn’t, due largely to Ion Marin’s reckless conducting. Twenty years later Naxos recorded it, live and complete, at the Rossini in Wildbad Festival; but this, too, proved unsatisfactory, upended by a vocally challenged Semiramide and some stand-andstare (as opposed to boy‑racer) conducting.

All this talk of conductors might seem odd given that with Semiramide ears are invariably turned to the voices. So let it be said that the new Semiramide, the lavishly gifted Russian coloratura Albina Shagimuratova, she of the shining high E, and Daniela Barcellona, our finest contemporary Arsace, are both superb. ‘Serbami ognor’ is sublime but go PH O T O G R A P H Y

D U N C A N

: R U S S E L L

22 GRAMOPHONE RECORDINGS OF THE YEAR 2018

Click on a CD cover to buy/stream from gramophone.co.uk

read next page

My Bookmarks

Buy this Book
Skip to main content