Skip to main content
Read page text
page 16
48.01 Switched off The media has been a political football in Argentina for years. Now, as Irene Caselli reports, people are losing confidence in local news and are looking for alternatives 48(01): 14/17 | DOI: 10.1177/0306422019842084 ARGENTINA'S ELECTION MACHINE is revving up ahead of the presidential election in October. But as journalists and media owners struggle, people are looking to other, less traditional outlets for their news. And that is worrying commentators who blame the election in Brazil of the far-right populist president Jair Bolsonaro, in part on the influence of unreliable Whatsapp groups and “fake news” sites. They wonder whether there could be a similar rise in populism in Argentina where people are losing confidence in the established local media. The crisis in journalism is acute. Newspapers and news agencies are closing, journalists are losing their jobs and people say they do not trust traditional news outlets any more. Since Mauricio Macri took over as president of Argentina three years ago, more than 3,000 journalists have lost their jobs, according to the Forum of Argentine Journalism (Fopea). El Gráfico, one of Latin America's most prestigious sport magazines, closed down in 2018 after 99 years on the market; the Englishlanguage daily Buenos Aires Herald disappeared after 140 years; and regional media laid off workers and contributors including at Río Negro, Patagonia's largest newspaper. The private national news agency Diaros y Noticias (Dyn) closed in November 2017, and in June 2018 the state-run agency Telam laid off journalists and its overall output went down. “Dyn was the only strong and independent agency in Argentina,” said Daniel Dessein, president of La Gaceta, the largest newspaper in north-western Argentina. “It reported on what happened in every province beyond Buenos Aires. Now, in terms of information, provinces have fewer channels to learn about what happens in the rest of the country. It is generating an insularity effect.” Martín Becerra, Argentina's leading media analyst, told Index that there were “broad consequences for freedom of expression” after these closures. “Society as a whole is affected by the decline of sources for local and regional information as well as professionally edited perspectives,” he said. Dessein agrees: "Democracy is undoubtedly affected by the decline in the journalistic flow, quality and rigour and by the decline of diversity and plurality of voices. All this affects public debate.” In response to this crisis other outlets are setting up shop. Chani Guyot worked for 20 years as an editor at La Nación, one of Argentina's largest newspapers. In 2017, he left his role as editor-in-chief and started Redacción, a digital enterprise dedicated to local stories. Guyot views Redacción as an antidote to the media crisis: “We claim we are doing human journalism,” he said. The publication, which finances itself thanks to private donations and a membership model, focuses on social issues that are not covered by other media. Redacción is part of a new landscape of digital media that create alternative coverage. Chequeado, Cosecha Roja, Revista Anfibia, Society as a whole is affected by the decline of sources for local and regional information as well as professionally edited perspectives 14INDEXONCENSORSHIP.ORG
page 17
SPECIAL REPORT Latfem, lavaca and Futurock radio, which are funded by members or thanks to grants, are among the most prestigious. For Hinde Pomeraniec, culture editor at the Infobae news portal, it is social networks, which are providing the diversity of opinions and information that the media now lack. “When I get asked what to read in order to get a balanced opinion, what I recommend is to follow specific journalists more than media,” she told Index. “Because you may find very rigorous journalists working for media that you do not trust.” Néstor Sclauzero, news manager of the staterun TV Pública, and president of Fopea, also believes that the digital world is creating new opportunities. In television, for example, costs have become much lower, giving regional media new opportunities. “Before, it was impossible to set up a TV station. Now with a smartphone and a laptop you can produce a decent TV report and make it circulate,” he said. The crisis which has struck Argentina’s traditional media is not unlike what is happening worldwide, where the painful transition into the digital age has led to layoffs. What makes the crisis of Argentina's media more acute is that it went through a brief period of bonanza just as the rest of the world started readjusting some 10 years ago. Under the previous presidency of Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, the government poured millions into advertising that partly financed the creation of new media aligned to the government. It was part of Fernández de Kirchner’s battle against private media concentration. For example, over the 2009-2015 period, pro-government Grupo Veintitrés was the largest receiver of advertising funds, receiving $53 million, according to La Nación newspaper. That money partly financed the opening of new media, such as the newspaper Tiempo Argentino. The connection to Fernández de Kirchner was apparent in the paper's editorial position, which was supportive of the government's social-oriented policies and vocal against the opposition – so much so that critics accused it of publishing propaganda. When Macri took over, Grupo Veintitrés saw its close relationship with the government end abruptly. The owners disappeared, leaving journalists stranded without pay. At Tiempo Argentino, staff got together and started functioning as a co-operative, which is still going strong after three years. “Advertising was supposed to be an incentive, but it had two limitations: it concentrated on traditional media at a time when digital media were gaining ground, and it did not actually improve the quality of journalism,” said Adriana Amado, president of Infociudadana, an NGO dedicated to improving the quality of information for citizens. “It was like steroids. When the money came to an end, the muscles did not last.” The crisis hit all media, regardless of ideology, because all benefited from government advertising. However, given Argentina's concentrated media market was in the capital, Buenos Aires, those who took the hardest hit were smaller, regional media. Things became even harder in 2018, when the economy shrank by 2.8% and inflation hit a 27-year high of 47.6%. ➔ ELSEWHERE IN LATIN AMERICA... Social networks and online media are the new ways journalists have found to produce independent news and circumvent government control IN VENEZUELA, WHERE the government of Nicolás Maduro has kept news coverage under control over the past years and reporters have been arrested and harassed for their coverage, digital media such as ArmandoInfo or Efecto Cocuyo have become a source of independent information both inside and outside the country. In Paraguay, where there are no legal limits on media concentration, El Surtidor was born in 2016 as an antidote to the mainstream narrative. It is a visual journalism platform where features are often presented as comics. It is led by a notfor-profit co-operative of journalists and mainly sustained by grants and a membership model. In Brazil, the membership model has made it possible for media such as Agência Pública to carry out investigations into environmental or social issues that are not usually tackled by established media. 15 INDEXONCENSORSHIP.ORG

Page Text

View plaintext

48.01

Switched off

The media has been a political football in Argentina for years. Now, as Irene Caselli reports, people are losing confidence in local news and are looking for alternatives 48(01): 14/17 | DOI: 10.1177/0306422019842084

ARGENTINA'S ELECTION MACHINE is revving up ahead of the presidential election in October. But as journalists and media owners struggle, people are looking to other, less traditional outlets for their news.

And that is worrying commentators who blame the election in Brazil of the far-right populist president Jair Bolsonaro, in part on the influence of unreliable Whatsapp groups and “fake news” sites. They wonder whether there could be a similar rise in populism in Argentina where people are losing confidence in the established local media.

The crisis in journalism is acute. Newspapers and news agencies are closing, journalists are losing their jobs and people say they do not trust traditional news outlets any more.

Since Mauricio Macri took over as president of Argentina three years ago, more than 3,000 journalists have lost their jobs, according to the Forum of Argentine Journalism (Fopea).

El Gráfico, one of Latin America's most prestigious sport magazines, closed down in 2018 after 99 years on the market; the Englishlanguage daily Buenos Aires Herald disappeared after 140 years; and regional media laid off workers and contributors including at Río Negro, Patagonia's largest newspaper.

The private national news agency Diaros y Noticias (Dyn) closed in November 2017, and in June 2018 the state-run agency Telam laid off journalists and its overall output went down.

“Dyn was the only strong and independent agency in Argentina,” said Daniel Dessein, president of La Gaceta, the largest newspaper in north-western Argentina. “It reported on what happened in every province beyond Buenos Aires. Now, in terms of information, provinces have fewer channels to learn about what happens in the rest of the country. It is generating an insularity effect.” Martín Becerra, Argentina's leading media analyst, told Index that there were “broad consequences for freedom of expression” after these closures. “Society as a whole is affected by the decline of sources for local and regional information as well as professionally edited perspectives,” he said.

Dessein agrees: "Democracy is undoubtedly affected by the decline in the journalistic flow, quality and rigour and by the decline of diversity and plurality of voices. All this affects public debate.”

In response to this crisis other outlets are setting up shop. Chani Guyot worked for 20 years as an editor at La Nación, one of Argentina's largest newspapers. In 2017, he left his role as editor-in-chief and started Redacción, a digital enterprise dedicated to local stories.

Guyot views Redacción as an antidote to the media crisis: “We claim we are doing human journalism,” he said. The publication, which finances itself thanks to private donations and a membership model, focuses on social issues that are not covered by other media.

Redacción is part of a new landscape of digital media that create alternative coverage. Chequeado, Cosecha Roja, Revista Anfibia,

Society as a whole is affected by the decline of sources for local and regional information as well as professionally edited perspectives

14INDEXONCENSORSHIP.ORG

read next page

My Bookmarks

Buy this Book
Skip to main content