Skip to main content
Read page text
page 66
66 The New Woman Behind the Camera Andrea Nelson (ed.) National Gallery of Art 978-1942884743 £ 47.95 This sweeping, ambitious, and groundbreaking survey of global photography by women from the 1920s to the 1950s aims to rewrite the history of modern photography by placing female practitioners squarely within that narrative. Spotlighting the work of more than 120 women from over twenty countries, The New Woman Behind the Camera seeks to provide a ‘synthetic study focused on the transnational realities of modernism and the intersecting and tangent lines of photographic practice being pursued by woman’, as curator Andrea Nelson phrases it in her Preface. That synthetic, transnational, and global study counters both the notion of a comprehensive survey, which this exhibition determinedly resists, and the naturalised narrative that places the advances of modern photography squarely in the hands of male photographers in the United States and Europe. The richly-illustrated catalogue anticipates a wide-scale exhibition of the same name with over two hundred photographs, magazines, and photobooks postponed by the pandemic but due to be shown at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York and the National Gallery, Washington D.C. The problem with identity-based projects, as Nelson is quick to acknowledge, is that they can be seen to lump together a heterogeneous group of practitioners under one heading, thus erasing differences in class, nationality, ethnicity, race, and individuals. Such thematic homogenisation was often rejected by the modern women themselves, who, to paraphrase critic Abigail Solomon-Godeau, pursued such unconventional lives and defined themselves so individualistically that they had neither need nor desire for collective emancipatory struggle. It is equally problematic to label all women who worked in the early twentieth century as ‘New Women’, a term that emerged out of Central Europe but came to represent a broad swathe of emancipatory modes of self-positioning and self-fashioning vis-à-vis patriarchy. Yet, women globally have faced similar barriers and their contributions to photographic history have been consistently overlooked for a variety of reasons, ranging from plain sexism to work that failed to conform to established standards. The exhibition and catalogue are thus in many respects recuperative, highlighting the output of unknown photographers as well as complicating the legacies of those whose work is iconic but often circumscribed. The photography of Germaine Krull belongs to the latter category, for example; her Métale photobook was widely celebrated at the time for its renditions of industrial architecture, but its reception has tended to overshadow her prodigious output of human subjects less aligned with the technophilic bias of modernist criticism. Similarly, women’s Germaine Krull, Eiffel Tower (1928) Germaine Krull, Untitled, Study for ‘The Nude’ (1924)
page 67
books 67 Annelise Kretschmer, Young Woman (1946) Tsuneko Sasamoto, Ginza 4 Chome P.X. (1946) Jeanne Mandello, Self-Portrait, Montevideo (c. 1942–1943) photographs of children or domestic subjects have been deemed less remarkable contributions to the progressive discourse of modernity. At stake, as Nelson argues, is a reconfiguration of the history of modernism itself, whose concerns are far more complicated and contradictory than hegemonic, masculinist accounts imply, and wherein women’s contributions have been steady and central rather than marginal and occasional. Six catalogue essays complement Nelson’s critical introduction and presumably outline the broad themes that might reconfigure the field: women and studio photography, photographs of children, women and the picture press, reportage from Africa, modern bodies, and fashion photography in Berlin. Though offering compelling and highly readable overviews of relevant themes, the essays are broad and descriptive to the point of subverting the pursuit of meaningful critical terms that would help us recast historical reception. Such a task will be left to subsequent history writing, facilitated by the work begun in this catalogue, and which must include research by women of colour who are notably absent from this compendium. Importantly, however, material familiar to scholars has been made accessible to a broad public, who will no doubt find the hundreds of excellent photographs by women both fascinating and inspiring. Unknown photographers are juxtaposed with more familiar names, Eslanda Goode Robeson, African Journey (1945) emphatically expanding our understanding of what modernist photography looked like throughout the world. Kim Sichel’s engaging essay on western women who photograph in Africa bears the heaviest burden of representing the global dimension of this exhibition, as it is the only essay to systematically address the colonial gaze in the context of a continent’s history. In the absence of known women photographers in Africa in the early twentieth century, Sichel hones in on ethnographic photographs taken by European and American women and postulates that as research continues, the work of African women will emerge from archives. Though references to and short histories of Asian, Middle Eastern, and South American photographers are interspersed throughout the catalogue, no further sustained essays on other non-western modernism have been included. Instead, those non-Western episodes have been woven into the larger thematic essays, most notably in Nelson’s account of studio photography, where the reader gains insights into particular Japanese, African American, and Turkish practices. The paradoxical aim of such an expansive exhibition and catalogue, however, is to obliterate itself. As Nelson admits, ‘…one of the ironies of organizing an exhibition of women artists is that the ultimate goal is to eradicate the very category of “women artists”’ in favour of a history of modernist photography in which men and women play equal and sustaining roles. Categories such as quality and influence, both of which have been used to denigrate women’s contributions, will cede to more compelling and productive discussions of photographers’ critical orientations to the different iterations of modernity across the globe. Originality of photographic vision extends beyond the strictures of modernist formalist innovation, while research has shown that questions of influence are complicated as the case of Lucia Moholy and László MoholyNagy, one of the foremost theoreticians of modern photography, has made evident. As it happens, women have been steering the development of modern photography all along. — Sabine Kriebel

66

The New Woman Behind the Camera Andrea Nelson (ed.) National Gallery of Art 978-1942884743 £ 47.95

This sweeping, ambitious, and groundbreaking survey of global photography by women from the 1920s to the 1950s aims to rewrite the history of modern photography by placing female practitioners squarely within that narrative. Spotlighting the work of more than 120 women from over twenty countries, The New Woman Behind the Camera seeks to provide a ‘synthetic study focused on the transnational realities of modernism and the intersecting and tangent lines of photographic practice being pursued by woman’, as curator Andrea Nelson phrases it in her Preface. That synthetic, transnational, and global study counters both the notion of a comprehensive survey, which this exhibition determinedly resists, and the naturalised narrative that places the advances of modern photography squarely in the hands of male photographers in the United States and Europe. The richly-illustrated catalogue anticipates a wide-scale exhibition of the same name with over two hundred photographs, magazines, and photobooks postponed by the pandemic but due to be shown at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York and the National Gallery, Washington D.C. The problem with identity-based projects, as Nelson is quick to acknowledge, is that they can be seen to lump together a heterogeneous group of practitioners under one heading, thus erasing differences in class, nationality, ethnicity, race, and individuals. Such thematic homogenisation was often rejected by the modern women themselves, who, to paraphrase critic Abigail Solomon-Godeau, pursued such unconventional lives and defined themselves so individualistically that they had neither need nor desire for collective emancipatory struggle. It is equally problematic to label all women who worked in the early twentieth century as ‘New Women’, a term that emerged out of Central Europe but came to represent a broad swathe of emancipatory modes of self-positioning and self-fashioning vis-à-vis patriarchy. Yet, women globally have faced similar barriers and their contributions to photographic history have been consistently overlooked for a variety of reasons, ranging from plain sexism to work that failed to conform to established standards. The exhibition and catalogue are thus in many respects recuperative, highlighting the output of unknown photographers as well as complicating the legacies of those whose work is iconic but often circumscribed. The photography of Germaine Krull belongs to the latter category, for example; her Métale photobook was widely celebrated at the time for its renditions of industrial architecture, but its reception has tended to overshadow her prodigious output of human subjects less aligned with the technophilic bias of modernist criticism. Similarly, women’s

Germaine Krull, Eiffel Tower (1928)

Germaine Krull, Untitled, Study for ‘The Nude’ (1924)

My Bookmarks


Skip to main content