A good question
JANET WOOTTON ‘We still need pioneers’
Constance Coltman was a pioneer of women’s ordination. The book Constance: Pioneer, pastor, preacher grew out of a gathering of global pioneers to mark the centenary of her ordination.
It was good to celebrate, but – hang on! When the Revd Mia Smith, Chaplain of Somerville College, where Constance initially studied, gave the centenary homily in the College Chapel, she said: ‘I found myself becoming angry. One hundred years? But 2,000 years ago Jesus ordained a woman, Mary Magdalene, as an apostle – one who is sent to tell – to go and tell others about the risen Christ.’
At the global gathering, we heard from people of Orthodox and Roman Catholic backgrounds, where the ordination of women to the priesthood is still a distant dream.
But even where churches are technically open to women’s ordained leadership, they often reflect, rather than challenging, the prejudices of a patriarchal world. In Switzerland, although women were ordained in 1918, as late as 2014 church leaders were expressing fears about the ‘feminisation’ of the church.
Speaking from a Guyanese context, the Revd Patricia Sheerattan-Bisnauth described boys and girls being treated differently from birth: ‘There is a common saying, “You tie your heifer; I will loose my bull.” The message is that the public space is man’s domain . . . males will often position themselves on a street corner and vie with each other in their moves to embarrass and harass girls and women passing by.’ Of course, in recent years, the churches’ horrifying complicity in the widespread abuse of women and children has come to light in every culture.
The Revd Ellen Nachali Mulenga, a minister in the United Church of Zambia, shows how churches have combined societal injustices with patriarchal theologies. ‘There is no need to advocate for the empowerment of a girl, as she is expected to be taken care of by her husband … The same is transferred to the church … Women think leadership is for men.’ Again, this unthinking collusion of theology and culture exists in every corner of the world.
Constance Coltman was a true pioneer, in that she opened the way to women and girls to greater equality in church and society. In the words of the Revd Dr Susan Durber, preaching at the Thanksgiving Service: ‘She stands in a great line of tradition, of women who learned and dared to be “first”, a line which we can join too today.’
It breaks my heart to say it, but women are still treated unequally in society and church. We still need pioneers.
‘Churches reflect the world’s prejudices’
Janet Wootton is a retired Congregational minister and the editor of Constance: Pioneer, Pastor, Preacher (pictured right) published by the United Reformed Church. It is available from urc.shop.co.uk
KIRSTY THORPE ‘We are still far from mutual respect’
See a photograph of the central platform in Westminster Central Hall, when the uniting assembly of the United Reformed Church took place in 1972, and you can easily spot most of the women by their hats.
Just a handful of female figures made it onto the stage among the black cassocks of the ordained men that day. You might have been forgiven for wondering whether the recognition of women as ordained ministers, more than 50 years earlier, had altered the public face Congregationalism in these islands at all.
Things look different now, at least on the face of things. You can’t attend General Assembly without encountering many gifted and significant women, lay and ordained. There are no roles within the URC which being female debars you from, and our Equal Opportunities and Diversity Policy Statement reads well.
But there’s a gap between our rhetoric and reality. True, the number of women who are ministers of Word and Sacrament and ChurchRelated Community Workers (CRCW) increases yearly. We are approaching equal numbers of women and men in pastoral charge, and there are more active women CRCWs than men. On the other hand, the denomination is still far from embodying mutual respect between women and men at all levels of church life.
How can you measure this except in terms of anecdotal evidence? One easy pointer, like those hats from 1972, is the presence of women among Synod Moderators. It took until 1990 for the first woman Synod Moderator to be appointed, and the current balance of nine men and four women is broadly typical of the past three decades.
Some might say that a continuing lack of
‘I still hear about women being bullied’
Reform | June 2021 | 23